Supreme Court in the case of Union of
India Vs Ibrahim Uddin and Anr1 and a judgment of a learned Single
Judge of this Court ... John Francisco Serrao, 2
wherein the decision in the case of Ibrahim Uddin (Supra) was
followed.
10. The lend support to the submission that
Kerala and another, AIR
2011 SC 559, Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin and another, (2012) 8
SCC 148 and Andisamy Chettiar vs. Subburaj Chettiar ... matters of Malyalam Plantations Limited,
Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin, Andisamy Chettiar and Jagdish
Prasad (supra), Exhs.33 and 34 filed by the petitioners
reported in ( 2001) 1 SCC 309 and Union of India v.
Ibrahim Uddin and another , reported in (2012) 8 SCC 148.
9. In order ... Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin
and another (supra) and it has been laid down as follows
Supreme Court in the case of Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin ,
reported in 2013 AIR SCW 2752 and more particularly paragraphs ... Supreme Court in the case of Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin
(supra). He distinguished the said judgment on the ground that since the
petitioner
Supreme Court in case of Union of India vs.
Ibrahim Uddin and another - (2012) 8 SCC 148. In this
case, the Hon'ble Supreme ... relevant observations, in the aforesaid regard in the
case of Ibrahim Uddin (supra), at paragraphs 49 and 52 read
as follows:
"49. An application
judgment of the Apex Court in Union of India V/s.
Ibrahim Uddin and Another1. He would also rely upon judgment of the
Madras High ... Appellate Courts.
20) Reliance by Mr. Naphade on judgment of Ibrahim Uddin
(supra) does not cut any ice. In the present case, Defendant-tenants
produced
judgment of the Apex Court in Union of India V/s.
Ibrahim Uddin and Another1. He would also rely upon judgment of the
Madras High ... Appellate Courts.
20) Reliance by Mr. Naphade on judgment of Ibrahim Uddin
(supra) does not cut any ice. In the present case, Defendant-tenants
produced
judgment of the Apex Court in Union of India V/s.
Ibrahim Uddin and Another1. He would also rely upon judgment of the
Madras High ... Appellate Courts.
20) Reliance by Mr. Naphade on judgment of Ibrahim Uddin
(supra) does not cut any ice. In the present case, Defendant-tenants
produced
Furthermore, he distinguished the judgment in Union of India V/s.
Ibrahim Uddin & Anr. reported in (2012) 8 SCC 148, by asserting that ... case, the Division Bench, after considering the
principles laid down in Ibrahim Uddin (supra), decided an application
under Order 41 Rule 27 (1) (aa) before
Furthermore, he distinguished the judgment in Union of India V/s.
Ibrahim Uddin & Anr. reported in (2012) 8 SCC 148, by asserting that ... case, the Division Bench, after considering the
principles laid down in Ibrahim Uddin (supra), decided an application
under Order 41 Rule 27 (1) (aa) before
