matters under the MRTU Act,
stands expressly, or in any event impliedly overruled by at
least two subsequent decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme ... Nandram,
there was no question of any express or implied overruling.
9. Typically, where a doubt is cast upon the decision of a
coordinate Bench
matters under the MRTU Act,
stands expressly, or in any event impliedly overruled by at
least two subsequent decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme ... Nandram,
there was no question of any express or implied overruling.
9. Typically, where a doubt is cast upon the decision of a
coordinate Bench
matters under the MRTU Act,
stands expressly, or in any event impliedly overruled by at
least two subsequent decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme ... Nandram,
there was no question of any express or implied overruling.
9. Typically, where a doubt is cast upon the decision of a
coordinate Bench
matters under the MRTU Act,
stands expressly, or in any event impliedly overruled by at
least two subsequent decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme ... Nandram,
there was no question of any express or implied overruling.
9. Typically, where a doubt is cast upon the decision of a
coordinate Bench
matters under the MRTU Act,
stands expressly, or in any event impliedly overruled by at
least two subsequent decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme ... Nandram,
there was no question of any express or implied overruling.
9. Typically, where a doubt is cast upon the decision of a
coordinate Bench
matters under the MRTU Act,
stands expressly, or in any event impliedly overruled by at
least two subsequent decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme ... Nandram,
there was no question of any express or implied overruling.
9. Typically, where a doubt is cast upon the decision of a
coordinate Bench
Gosikhurd Project Ambadi,
Bhandara, Maharashtra Vidarbha Irrigation Development
Corporation (supra) stands impliedly overruled and based
8
(1991) 4 SCC 531
9
1995 Supp ... Gosikhurd Project Ambadi, Bhandara,
Maharashtra Vidarbha Irrigation Development Corporation
(supra) being impliedly overruled was raised but rejected by
the Division Bench of this Court
existed on the date when they arose. This only implies that
decision in Y.V. Rangaiah [(1983) 3 SCC 284] is confined to
the facts ... decision in Y.V. Rangaiah [(1983) 3 SCC
284] is impliedly overruled. However, as there is no declaration
Apex Court, subsequently, the earlier
judgment stands impliedly overruled. We do not
understand the propriety in citing the judgment which is
impliedly overruled ... judgment in the
case of Shilpa Thakur is held as impliedly overruled by the judgment
KHUNTE/ANSARI
WP-985.22-J.odt
10/14
in Anand
found.
16. N.C. Santhosh (supra) does seem to have impliedly overruled Canara
Bank (supra) by holding that the norms, prevailing on the date
