legislative intent that Section 52 of the
Easements Act, not being pari materia, ought not be relied on in
determining the scope and meaning ... Rent Act 1947 so as to make it pari materia. In other
words, it was submitted that, after the 1976 Amendment, the Rent
holding that the Rent Act and the PSCC Act are pari materia statutes. Ms. Parikh made reference to several judgments in support of her submission ... meaning of the expressions can be derived from a cognate pari materia statute, whether earlier or later. He further submitted that the well settled rules
which I am going to refer to herein below, are in pari materia to the provisions of The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 [herein ... National Human Rights Commission / State Human Rights Commission are in pari materia to the provisions relating to the Functions, Powers and Procedure of the Commissions
from the fact that Section 21 of
the NIA Act is pari materia to Section 34 of the erstwhile Prevention of
Terrorism Act with ... offences, and civil and criminal legislations cannot be
construed as being pari materia. He submits that the statutory interpretation
adopted in respect of civil legislation
manner?
II. Are the EFL Act and Vesting Act in pari materia?
III. On whom the burden of proof lies to show that a particular ... extremely difficult to think that both the enactments are in pari
materia.
43. Forceful arguments were addressed by both sides regarding
as to whose burden
Civil Procedure Code were held to be in 'pari
materia' because both of them relate to the law of procedure. In my opinion ... pages 35-36:
"Where there are different statutes 'in pari
materia', though made at different times, or
even expired and not referring
Solicitor General, by pointing out that unless those provisions are in pari materia with Payment of Bonus Act,1965 , the same cannot be cited ... decisions by the courts construing similar provision of an enactment in pari materia. The object behind the application of the said rule of construction
counsel for the 2nd respondent submitted that when two enactments are pari materia, it is open for the Court to read the provisions ... seventh edition) at pages 135 and 146;
"(1) Statutes in pari materia :
Where Acts of Parliament are in pari materia, that
Court had considered the
provisions of Haryana Act which are in pari materia with the provisions of the
Tamil Nadu Act in relation ... supra) with the submissions that the said provision has
been in pari materia with Section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu
Haridwar v. Harish Malhotra ) to contend
that the later enactment is ?pari materia?.
10. The Learned Advocate General further contended that Rules 1959 and
Rules ... Rules are different, they
cannot be treated as pari materia. The definition under one Rule cannot
be read into the other, unless there
