case of
respondent No.1, the defective and incomplete ACRs for
the years 1992-1993, 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 were
considered ... disturbing his
seniority. The DPC apart from taking the defective and
incomplete ACRs of respondent No.1 for the years
been left
incomplete and his empanellment as Additional Secretary/Secretary to the
Government of India was considered on the basis of incomplete ACRs. The
appellant ... empanellment for the post of Secretary was not based on incomplete ACRs.
The appellant then contended that some officer were biased against him and
their
been reviewed by the reviewing authority and, therefore, it was an incomplete ACR.
2. A reference had been made to a Bench of five Judges ... ernment orders.
4. In so far the second issue regarding an ACR being incomplete without being reviewed and in such circumstances it not being advisable
Reviewing and/or Accepting Officers have
retired, the below benchmark ACR gradings have to be ignored, would be
to read something into the decision which ... deals with the situation as to what should be done with
incomplete ACR gradings i.e. where the ACR proforma has been filled
up only
treated as incomplete ACRs and the previous completed ACRs of the applicant be provided to the Applicant to enable him to make his representations against
contains consolidated instructions in respect of writing of ACRs. The said Government Order specifically states that ACRs have to be written 'promptly ... against the officer reported upon. The procedure regarding the assessment on incomplete ACRs, which is available in the counter affidavit filed by the respective parties
with uniform set of guidelines, do not nullify the effect of the
ACRs already marked by the existing system. The guidelines
indicated by the High ... ACRs of all the officers considered for the subject promotion which have
been circulated for perusal of this Court, are found to be incomplete
contains consolidated instructions in respect of writing of ACRs. The said Government Order specifically states that ACRs have to be written 'promptly ... against the officer reported upon. The procedure regarding the assessment on incomplete ACRs, which is available in the counter affidavit filed by the respective parties
accepting authority once again has not granted any grade, therefore, the ACR
was incomplete and no proper procedure was followed. When the Reporting
Authority ... from challenging the incomplete ACR by preferring the
present petition later on. Even otherwise, the ACR which is found incomplete
and wherein the Reporting Authority
ACR, disclosure of ACRs, communication of adverse remarks, disposal of
representations, the decision regarding declaration of any ACR as
complete or incomplete and issuing ... Report Certificate' in lieu of
an incomplete ACR etc. comes under the exclusive domain of the State
Government.
12. The respondent no. 4 filed
