Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

give strength to his argument that the respondents cannot take inconsistent pleadings in different writ petitions. He submitted that in earlier two writ petitions filed

trial court assessing the pleading, evidence and also inconsistencies pleaded by the plaintiff, rightly dismissed the suit. First Appellate Court without any materials on record

same will not only result in allowing inconsistent and alternative pleadings but it shall also amount to displace Signature Not Verified Digitally Signed By:ASHEESH ... amendments sought for, shall not only result in allowing inconsistent and alternative pleadings but it will also displace the plaintiff completely from the admissions made

permission on the ground that such permission would permit him to plead inconsistent pleas before the Court. At the same time, it would be premature ... defendant can raise inconsistent pleas and inconsistent defense in the written statement, whereas it is not permissible to raise any inconsistent pleas in the plaint

smaller relief would be permissible provided that same is not inconsistent with pleadings of parties. 21 33. The High Court of Patna in the case ... order to the declaration sought for cannot be said to be inconsistent with pleadings or larger than the relief sought. Therefore even said contention does

tenant relationship between the parties. 29. However, pertinently, the respondents have inconsistently pleaded in their written statement that they had paid pagri to the landlord ... harmony with the earlier pleading of the respondents. Such mutually inconsistent pleas cannot be accepted. 30. Further, the onus to prove a fact rests

once his presence is proved at the spot. The rule of inconsistent pleadings is alien to criminal law and the inconsistency cannot be taken into

tenant relationship between the parties. 29. However, pertinently, the respondent has inconsistently pleaded in his written statement that he had paid pagri to the landlord ... versus Rajiv Jain Page No. 16/35 earlier pleading of the respondent. Such mutually inconsistent pleas cannot be accepted. 30. Further, the onus to prove

complainant. The complainant thus argued that the accused has firstly been pleading inconsistent stands and in any case has not put any probable defence

complainant thus argued that the accused has firstly been pleading inconsistent stands and in any case has not put any probable defence. The complainant further ... amount from the complainant. The accused has been inconsistent in his defence. Firstly, the accused pleaded that the cheques were C.C No. 3025/2017