Industrial Dispute--Gratuity Scheme--When region-cum-
industry principle is applicable--Whether gratuity should be
related to basic wage or consolidated wage--Whether
conditions prevailing ... Whether
a uniform scheme applicable to the entire industry on the
region-cum-industry basis should have been adopted instead
of schemes applicable to individual
from private
sector undertakings, the Tribunal fixed the wage scale on
region-cum-industry basis. It found that the company was a
very large ... need found wage, fair wage, to living wage.
The principle of region-cum-industry,the rule of relevancy
of comparable concerns, and the recognition
limited by its terms of
reference, which was not on industry-cum-region basis, but
one for each mill to consider the question of bonus ... into the question. There is in
our opinion no question of industry-cum-region approach in
the matter of a bonus dispute of this kind
would be proper to put greater emphasis on the industry part
of the industry-cum-region principle as that would put all
concerns ... same kind
in a particular region is small it is the region part of the
industry-cum-region formula which
(1) [1963] Supp
region or industry depends upon
varying factors. Where there are no comparable industries in
the region, the regional aspect of the region-cum-industry
formula ... where there are no
comparable industries in the region, the regional aspect of
the region-cum-industry formula must be given precedence.
That was what
company in the entire country, the question of application of the Industry-cum-Regional principle did not arise. It also held that finance ... service. The settlements are arrived at as package deals locally on industry-cum-region principle which is the basis laid down by the Supreme Court
clear therefore that the capacity of an industry to pay should be gauged on industry-cum-region basis after taking a fair cross-section ... same kind in a particular region is small it is the region part of the industry-cum-region formula which assumes importance particularly
November 1998 seeking to justify itsdemands on the basis of the region-cum-industry principle. Themanagement filed its Written Statements in the References. TheUnion inter ... region-cum-industry formula.There is no comparative evaluation by the Industrial Tribunal onthe basis of the industry-cum-region formula.
30. During the course
have been considered on the unit basis and not on the industry-cum-region basis. He referred to C. P. Transport Service Ltd. Nagpur ... particular industry in a given region.
8. In view of what we have said, the respondent 2 could have adopted the industry-cum-region basis
orders of Ghaziabad Unit of the Company; (3) What is an Industry-cum-Region Principle? (4) whether the Certifying Officer or the Appellate Authority ... region was considered by that appellate authority. Whereas the appellate authority in the present case did not consider the region-cum-Industry principle. He also
