trust deed the jurisdiction of this Court to do so is barred.
7. Clause 11(v) of the trust deed reads as under :-
"Clause ... scope of
a clause of the trust deed but an attempt to alter the object of
the trust deed, which is not contemplated
trust deed, intent of the settlor has to be seen. The
settlor made the trust irrevocable in clause 16 of the trust deed. It thus ... trust.
47. Plaintiffs contended that principles applied for interpreting the
articles of company cannot be applied for interpreting a trust deed.
This argument is without
Chapter XIII had been made
requesting the High Court to interpret the original Trust
deed in ,a particular manner, Such a plea was not taken ... even in this Court that
Ramfry, J. merely purported to interpret the original Trust
deed whether his interpretation is ,correct
settlement deed/trust deed--Whether
discretionary--Revocability under section 63- -Settlor's
power under U.S. deed--Extent of--Revenue's, option ... from settlement deeds--If proved, not taxable in India.
Interpretation of Document--U.S.A. or U.K settlement deeds
or trust deeds--Construction
corpus itself as
per the directions in the Trust Deed in clause 11 of the Trust
Deed."
(iv) "...The Settlor directed ... learned counsel for the petitioners attacking
the Trust deed and the Nizam's trust Deeds
Validation Act and the Validation Amendment Act
are therefore
interpretation of the settlement deeds
-- though it is true, some contentions of law are also
raised. The Commission has interpreted the trust deeds ... deeds is not correct, it would
not be a ground for interference in these appeals, since a
wrong interpretation of a deed of trust cannot
trust deed dated 11th October, 1939, and that the provisions of Section 16(1)(c) were not attracted to this trust and that the trust ... trust must essentially and basically be answered by the analysis and scrutiny of the specific clauses of that trust deed. Cases and authorities interpreting other
objects set out in the trust deed should be treated as equal components of the trust deed. We have, therefore, to read sub-clause ... other 18 clauses of the trust deed leave no doubt that the dominant purpose of the entire trust deed was clearly charitable. Even if some
case CIT v. Thanthi Trust [1982] 137 ITR 735 (Mad), while interpreting the trust deeds in question, that the charitable objects enumerated in the trust ... Thanthi Trust [1982] 137 ITR 735 (Mad) have been rendered in a proceeding between the same parties interpreting the very same trust deeds
Registrar, Public Trust and the First Additional District Judge
have not interpreted the Clauses 18 & 24 of the trust deed in its
true perspective ... clear that the Registrar, Public Trust
8
and the court below have rightly interpreted clause 18 of the trust
deed which does not require
