Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

Subhangi Tukaram Sawant vs R.H. Mendonca And Ors. on 21 September, 2000 Equivalent citations

doctrine of precedents has become an integral part of judicial discipline. The doctrine of precedent is a habit of following previous decisions within more ... same Tribunal. This is opposed to all principles of judicial discipline. If at all, the subsequent Bench of the Tribunal was of the opinion that

divergent to that of the earlier Division Bench in Hubtown. Therefore, judicial discipline, according to Dr. Saraf, demands that either we go by the earlier ... Union of India . These are essentially on the point of judicial discipline and a latter Division Bench being confronted with the earlier view directly adjudicating

divergent to that of the earlier Division Bench in Hubtown. Therefore, judicial discipline, according to Dr. Saraf, demands that either we go by the earlier ... Union of India . These are essentially on the point of judicial discipline and a latter Division Bench being confronted with the earlier view directly adjudicating

divergent to that of the earlier Division Bench in Hubtown. Therefore, judicial discipline, according to Dr. Saraf, demands that either we go by the earlier ... Union of India . These are essentially on the point of judicial discipline and a latter Division Bench being confronted with the earlier view directly adjudicating

judicial restraint, in my opinion, applies even in this realm. We should not forget other doctrines which are equally developed viz. Judicial Discipline and respect ... para 26) "26. Judicial discipline is self-discipline. It is an inbuilt mechanism in the system itself. Judicial discipline demands that when the decision

conducted yourself in a manner unbecoming of a Judicial Officer and failed to maintain Judicial discipline or propriety." 16. It is a settled position ... must be grasped that judicial discipline is self-discipline. The responsibility is self-responsibility. Judicial discipline is an inbuilt mechanism inherent in the system itself

view, it is settled law that the principle of judicial discipline requires that the orders of the higher appellate authorities should be followed unreservedly ... function under the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. The principles of judicial discipline require that the Orders of the higher appellate authorities should be followed unreservedly

urged that the learned Vice- Chairman not only deviated from the judicial discipline of respecting and following the views of the co-ordinate Benches ... milk collection and extension supervisors was unsustainable, the judicial discipline and judicial propriety warranted that the binding efficacy of the judgment of the Division Bench

The Commissioner Of Central Excise ... vs Bombay Dyeing And Manufacturing Co. Ltd on 14 June