decision is an authority for what it
decides and not what can logically be deduced therefrom. It is
equally well-settled that a little difference ... decision is its ratio and not
every observation found therein nor
what logically follows from the various
observations made in it. On this topic
this
data bank' have
passed. Therefore, there is no rational or logic for
again asking such apprentices to pass the written test
just because ... eligibility criteria. Mr.Yagnik submitted that
there is no rational or any logic for change in the
eligibility criteria and since the skill examination
(written
granting liberty to the official respondents to take the enquiry to its logical
conclusion by taking appropriate steps in accordance with law.
12. Mr. Chakraborty ... that
the complaints lodged by the petitioners are not taken to their logical conclusion
cannot, in the circumstances, be ruled out.
19. Be that
bank has also filed supplementary counter affidavit, but therein, no rationale or logic has been disclosed for making such classification. However, Sri D. Vaish, learned ... Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
12. The logic put forth by the respondent bank that the more qualified person will
candidates, it was found to be bereft of any logic and it was
also found to diminish the criteria of merit. It was found that
cause why the petitioner be not held entitled to appointment on
the logic presented by the petitioner mathematically in his address to the
Court ... position 108 which was the advertised quota
of Head Mistresses. By this logic, the petitioner has made out a case for
interference
void ab initio and non est by an extension of the same logic. The answering respondent has also referred to para 27 of the order ... them would be void ab initio and ipso facto following the logic laid down in Rajesh Guptas case (supra). In this regard, Rule
efficiency in services and the classification need not be scientifically
perfect or logically complete. In applying the wide language of Articles
these two sets of cases, one is able to mentally
rexognise the logic behind different outcomes. Under what circumstances
such a benefit can be extended ... 1987. It appears that this suit could not be taken to its
logical conclusion as same was dismissed for non-prosecution because of non
appearance
Amarendra Kumar Mohapatra & Ors vs State Of Orissa & Ors on 19 February, 2014
