Transport Corporation, Ahmedabad v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai
and anr.), 2007 ACJ 1279 (Manjuri Bera v. Oriental Insurance ... married sisters of the victim, as if the decision in
Manjuri Bera (supra) were an authority for the issue that it decided. Reference
was made
that they are not entitled to any
compensation whatsoever.
15. In Manjuri Bera vs. Oriental Insurance Company ... These aspects were highlighted in Smt. Manjuri Bera v. The
Oriental Insurance Co Ltd. and Anr. (2007) 10 SCC 643 :(SCC pp.
646-48, paras
counsel for the appellant by heavily relying on the case
of Manjuri Bera Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. and another , AIR
2007 SC 1474, Ranjan ... would be appropriate to quote
pargarph-12 of the case of Manjuri Bera (supra) -
"12. Judged in that background where a legal
representative
places reliance upon the
decision of the Apex Court in Smt.Manjuri
Bera vs Oriental Insurance Co.Ltd. , and the
reported decision of a Division ... relevant portions of the judgment in
Manavalgan 's case and Manjuri Bera
(supra).
15
7. In Manavalgan 's case the Division
Bench while
dependant, Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Smt.
Manjuri Bera vs. The Oriental Insurance Company Limited ... ratio of law as laid down in case of Smt. Manjuri
Bera (supra), it is clear that legal heir is entitled to compensation, even
dependant, Hon'ble Apex Court in
case of Smt. Manjuri Bera Vs. The Oriental Insurance Company Limited ... dependency. The ratio of law as laid down in f Smt. Manjuri Bera Vs.
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited and Anr. (supra), it is clear
Supreme Court in the case of Manjuri Bera
Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. , reported in AIR
2007 SC 1474 to buttress his argument that ... Supreme Court in the case of Manjuri Bera
(supra) has clearly held that even if there is no 'Loss of
Dependency', the claimant
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court
in Smt. Manjuri Bera Versus The Oriental Insurance Company
Limited and another ... learned counsel for the
respondents-claimants in Santosh Devi and Smt. Manjuri Bera's cases
(supra), are concerned, the same are not attracted
relevant portions of the judgment in
Manavalgan's case and Manjuri Bera (Supra)
7. In Manavalgan's case the Division Bench while
summarizing ... however the same in both cases.
(emphasis supplied)
8. In Manjuri Bera's case, the Apex Court held thus:
"16. Judged in that
relevant portions of the judgment in
Manavalgan's case and Manjuri Bera (Supra)
7. In Manavalgan's case the Division Bench while
summarizing ... however the same in both cases.
(emphasis supplied)
8. In Manjuri Bera's case, the Apex Court held thus:
"16. Judged in that
