marks in case of general candidates and 31.2 marks in the case of
SC/ST candidates out of a total of 65 marks that comprise ... marks
Civil Writ Petition No.5634 of 2009 -5-
for seniority and 25 marks for performance appraisals and 10 marks for
DPC interview. 36.4 marks
marks in three groups. The petitioner secured 50% marks in
Group-I and Group-II, however, he was awarded 12 out of 25 marks ... marks. He flunked by
half mark.
8. This Court is not oblivious of the fact that Courts cannot look
into the marks awarded by DPC
scale of 45 marks consisting of three segments i.e. Performance Appraisal
Reports (25 marks), seniority (10 marks) and DPC recommendations (10
marks). An eligible ... marks
(assured 8 marks) for seniority and 35 marks to areas where merit and
ability has a predominant role to play (PAR and DPC evaluation
that the Bench Mark for
the DPC held in March/ April 2002, was 'Very good'. According to
the petitioner, the norm of three ... result of the
recommendation made by the DPC. Certainly, if the Bench Mark
about
4 years when the first DPC was constituted on 03.07.2014
& about 3 year when second DPC was constituted on
27.04.2015. Therefore ... clear that 5 years past
service record was not upto mark when both the DPC's
were constituted. Hence the case of petitioner
Rules. The applicant-petitioner
alleged that the DPC has erred in applying the bench-mark of 'Very
Good' instead of 'Good ... DPC.
7. On 25.1.2011, the respondent UT Chandigarh took the
stand that in the review DPC, the applicant-petitioner has failed to
make mark
Promotion Committee (DPC) and
entitlement to promotion would require 12 marks. Thus the DPC in
question was required to consider the record of the candidates ... petitioner was graded as above average but the marks
allocated to him by the DPC for these 4 years
writ in the nature of Mandamus directing the respondents to reconvene the DPC meeting to reconsider the petitioner's case for promotion as Executive ... posts/services from lower group, while the Bench Mark will continue to be good, the DPC shall grade the officers as outstanding", very Good
DPC') was ordered to be
convened on the same day. However, no decision was taken and the
decision was deferred. The DPC, thereafter, again ... years the petitioner
earned 13 marks, so was the position with respondent no.3, who had 14
bench marks as on the date of consideration
ACRs/DPC
proceedings produced by the respondents
alongwith other relevant record.
It is admitted case of the parties that the
bench-mark for the post ... prescribed bench mark of 'Very
Good' and there is nothing wrong in the
assessment made by the DPC.
5. It is well settled
