graded fit (i.e. who meet
(he prescribed bench-mark) by the DPC shall be included
and arranged in the select panel in order ... graded 'unfit' (in terms of the prescribed bench-mark) by
the DPC shall not be included in the select panel. Thus,
there shall
Copy of Marks allotted by DPC Members in
DPC 2007 for the post of AGMs.
c) Attested Copy of Marks allotted by DPC Members ... provide
the information with respect to the DPC minutes as well as the interview
marks obtained by candidates, whose promotion was considered
paragraph 2 below) for overall grading to be given by the DPC, bench-mark for assessment of performance and the manner in which the select ... reference to the relevant bench-mark (Very Good or Good) prescribed for promotion.
3.2 Bench-mark for promotion
The DPC shall determine the merit
meet the prescribed bench-mark) by the DPC shall be included and arranged in the select panel in order to their inter-se seniority ... graded 'unfit' (in terms of the prescribed bench-mark) by the DPC shall not be included in the select panel. Thus, there shall
consideration were considered and each of them were found
having equal marks. The DPC on a finding that respondent no.3
was promoted
Raturi , decided on 8.7.2014 in regard to disclosure of marks of DPC
proceedings of other employees:
"This Court is of the view that ... also the marks given to the
candidates based on the said ACR grading/ratings and their interview marks
contained in the DPC proceedings
also the marks given to the candidates based on the said ACR
grading/ratings and their interview marks contained in the DPC proceedings
review DPC to be held, for the reason, learned counsel
for the respondent does not dispute that the bench mark to be achieved ... bench-mark for promotion from the rank of Commandant to Addl. DIG
is ‘Very Good’. The bench-mark ‘Very Good’ has been defined
years before the date of holding the DPC, if not
communicated earlier but are below bench mark would be
communicated within a period ... which have not been communicated, cannot be considered
by the DPC and the DPC is then to follow the same
procedure as prescribed in paragraph
Engineer (Civil) by the first
DPC, held on 13th June, 2011 while his juniors were promoted; that a 2nd
DPC was held ... relevant for evaluation by this DPC, he was again assessed unfit because
of the said two below bench mark gradings of the years
