Health Services Private ... on 25 January, 2018
ITA No 1429 of 2017 Medplus Health Services P Ltd Hyderabad.
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
Hyderabad ... 2017
(Assessment Year: 2012-13)
DCIT, Circle 16 ( 2 ) Vs M/s. Medplus Health
Hyderabad Services P. Ltd
Hyderabad
PAN: AAECM 9412 H
(Appellant) (Respondent
same has also been so held in the follozving case law:
( i) Medplus Health Services (p) Ltd. vs. ITO
ward 16(1) Hyderabad ... 11UA. And in support
of the assessee has quoted case law "medplus health
services(P) ltd. vs ito ward 16(1) Hyderabad
relied upon the cases of Bharat
Hari Singhania(207 ITR 1),Medplus Health Services P.Ltd.(158 ITD 105).
5.We have heard the rival ... method adopted by the assessee.
We find that in the case of Medplus Health Services P.Ltd.(supra)similar issue was
deliberated upon and decided
1967/2018
BETWEEN
1. SRI MADHUKAR REDDY
DIRECTOR OF M/S MEDPLUS
(A UNIT OF OPTIVAL HEALTH
SOLUTIONS PVT LTD.),
2. SRI. K SATYA MURALI ... KRISHNA
DIRECTOR OF M/S MEDPLUS
(A UNIT OF OPTIVAL HEALTH
SOLUTIONS PVT LTD)
BOTH ARE R/AT DOOR NO. 832
VINAYA MARGA MAIN ROAD
7762/Mum/2012 vide order dated
23.08.2013 Para 10.
7.3 Also refer Medplus Health Services P. Ltd. Vs. ITO (2016)
158 ITD 0105 (Trib ... viib) . In the case of Medplus Health
Services (P) Ltd vs ITO (supra), the ITAT, Hyderabad Coordinate Bench,
after taking into consideration various decisions
going on the left
side of road at Davanagere in front of Medplus store on
Hadadi Road, a speedy motorcycle bearing Registration
reliance placed by the Revenue on the case of M/s Medplus Health Services
2
3
Pvt. Ltd. Vs. the ITO, Ward 16(1), Hyderabad
other cities where the
respondent No.1 got a job in MEDPLUS at Hyderabad. Hence,
we shifted to Hyderabad residing at Flat ... respondent had started his own business. 1st respondent was
employed in MEDPLUS at Hyderabad. Later she joined 1st
respondent at Hyderabad with her child. During
DCIT, Circle 16 (2) Vs M/s. Medplus Health
Hyderabad Services Private Limited
Hyderabad
PAN: AAECM 9412H
(Appellant) (Respondent)
For Revenue: Smt. N. Swapna ... Block IT Towers, AC Guards, Masab
Tank, Hyderabad
2 M/s. Medplus Health Services P Ltd 5-9-13, F.No.707, 7th Floor,
Taramandal
Ashok Nagar Colony, Ashok Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500 020. 2. M/s. Medplus 65/1/1, Sisir Bhaduri Sarani, Kolkata - 700 006. 3. Principal Secretary
