conundrum in this appeal is: whether the contents of a
memory card/pendrive being electronic record as predicated in
Section ... obligatory to furnish a cloned copy of the contents of such
memory card/pendrive to the accused facing prosecution for an
alleged offence
opened and on opening,
one SIM card of Airtel and one SIM card of Reliance and one
.
memory card were taken out. It was found ... phone contains i.e. one SIM card of
Airtel and one SIM card of Reliance and one memory card
separately.
of
63 After laboratory examination
demands made by accused no. 1 were recorded in the
memory card in Nokia mobile handset given by PW-20 IO Shri
Desurkar and voice ... been deliberately
withheld.
16. The conversation has been recorded in the memory card
which was in the Nokia mobile handset provided
Malkhana:
(viii) Shirt got recovered from the accused.
(ix) An SD Memory Card stated to have been recovered from the
shirt of the accused ... recorded on the mobile phone and that he removed the SD memory card
which contained such conversations and kept it in his shirt pocket.
According
other, was video-graphed by Shri
Ajeet Tiwari on a memory card. He had prepared a copy
of the original recording from memory card ... card inserted in the card slot
of the video camera at the time of video recording. As
per petitioner's own pleadings, that memory
proved as A-1 to A-37 on such transcription.
8.13 Memory card containing such conversation was played during the trial
and complainant Sh. Praveen ... office
where he remained for two hours and that the memory card was played and he heard
the conversation again. Such transcription was prepared
scuffle between the
accused and the deceased was seized. The memory card
in the mobile was also seized. It is stated that the video ... seizure of the mobile phone and the
memory card from PW3 is proved by PW1 and also by
the evidence of PW3. The phone
proved the same. Parcel/Ex.Q1 (parcel
containing memory card,
He identified his signature bearing signature of
appearing at point X on file ... first
report, which was prepared on cover of memory card) &
26.04.2018 by CBI official and
proved the same. Ex.Article/PW3/C (plastic
During further
investigation, Munna also joined the investigation and produced the
memory card of 2GB which was having the recording of the same sting
which ... going to Vigilance Office
someone gave envelope having a memory card to him and told to give
the same at Vigilance Office. He further stated
supplementary affidavit by way of examination-in-chief along
with memory cards/chips of the mobile phones, compact disc
(CD) and transcript of conversations recorded ... memory
cards/chips of the mobile phones. In the said application, the
appellant stated that various telephonic conversations happened
between the parties during the period
