In Reference vs Lallu @ Suresh Kewat on 11 December, 2015
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
mitigating circumstances and that there has to be overall
consideration of the circumstances regarding the accused as also
the offence. Some aggravating circumstances were also ... Supreme Court insisted upon the mitigating circumstances
being balanced against the aggravating circumstances. The
aggravating circumstances were described as under:
Crl.A.Nos.966/2013
crime has shocked our
judicial conscious. There are no extenuating or mitigating
circumstances whatsoever in the case. We agree that a real
and abiding concern ... nature and circumstances of the
crime and all the relevant circumstances.
(iv) A balance-sheet of aggravating and mitigating
circumstances has to be drawn
crime has shocked our
judicial conscious. There are no extenuating or mitigating
circumstances whatsoever in the case. We agree that a real
and abiding concern ... nature and circumstances of the
crime and all the relevant circumstances.
(iv) A balance-sheet of aggravating and mitigating
circumstances has to be drawn
according to the learned Senior Counsel, having regard to the above
mitigating circumstances, the punishment may be reduced. He would further
submit that the petitioner ... also to the
mitigating circumstances. It is well known that the aggravating circumstances
relate to the crime and the mitigating circumstances relate to the criminal
submitted that death sentence
cannot be imposed if there is any mitigating circumstance in favour of the
accused and for imposition of such sentence ... determination of sentence. The said circumstances
read as follows:
Mitigating circumstances - In the exercise of its discretion in the above cases,
the court shall take
Courts should consider the
aggravating circumstances relate to the crime while
mitigating circumstances relate to the criminal. A
balance sheet cannot be drawn ... impose any sentence without taking into
account all aggravating and mitigating circumstances."
9. In the aforementioned Division Bench judgment, considering the
aggravating and mitigating
nature and circumstances of the crime and all the
relevant circumstances.
iv) A balance-sheet of aggravating and mitigating circumstances
has to be drawn ... doing so the mitigating
circumstances have to be accorded full weightage and a just
balance has to be struck between the aggravating and the
mitigating
delivered the judgment of the court, took notice of the mitigating circumstances in the case, They were summed up as follows:
There was some probability ... drunkenness: (9) childhood.
Indeed these-are not the only aggravating or mitigating circumstances which should be considered when sentencing an offender. The list
argued that respondent nos.111 who have
pleaded mitigating circumstances in the main petition
cannot be heard on that aspect since mitigating
circumstances ... appear in the revenue
records.
17. It was argued that the mitigating circumstances
can always be pressed into service at any point of time