State Of Uttar Pradesh vs Mohammad Nooh on 30 September, 1957
Equivalent citations: 1958 AIR 86, 1958 SCR 595, AIR 1958 SUPREME COURT ... Sarkar
PETITIONER:
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
Vs.
RESPONDENT:
MOHAMMAD NOOH
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
30/09/1957
BENCH:
BOSE, VIVIAN
BENCH:
BOSE, VIVIAN
DAS, SUDHI
vice verse, [1969] 3 SCR 203; State of Uttar
Pradesh v. Muhammad Nooh, [1958] SCR 595; Collector of
Customs, Calcutta v. East India Commercial ... observations of this Court in
State Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammad Nooh , [1958] SCR 595, where
it has been said:
.... an order of dismissal passed
Madras [1966] 2 SCR
229 and State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammad Nooh [1958] SCR
595; distinguished.
The question whether a provision is ultra vires ... principles laid down in Raleigh Investment
Company's case or Mohammad Nooh's case to a case like the
present where there
first of these cases is : The State of Uttar Pradesh v.
Mohammad Nooh .(1) On April 20, 1948 the District
Superintendent of Police passed ... order of dismissal
against the respondent Mohammad Nooh who was a head
constable. The respondent filed an appeal to the Deputy
Inspector-General of Police
referred to.
The State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammad Nooh (1958) S.C.R.
595, not applicable.
JUDGMENT:
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal ... decision of this Court in The State of Uttar Pradesh v.
Mohammed Nooh (2).
It is well settled by a series of decisions of this
have not been
exhausted. [522 C]
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammad Nooh, [1958] S.C.R.
596, 605, relied on.
There are at least ... principle of natural justice. [523 D]
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammad Nooh, [1958] S.C.R.
596, 605, referred to.
In the present case
Munuswamy
[1988] Suppl. SCC 651 and State of U.P. v. Mohd. Nooh
[1958] SCR 595, referred to. (874-C)
For appreciating a case ... Commissioner
and the Commissioner. (876-G)
State of U.P. v. Mohd. Nooh. [1958] SCR 595, relied on.
JUDGMENT:
CIVIL., APPELATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal
Limitation Act.
In The State of Uttar Pradesh Vs. Mohammad Nooh [1958
SCR 595] Vivian Bose, J. held that justice should be done ... noticing the earlier Constitution Benches decision
of this Court in Mohammad Nooh (supra), Madan Gopal Rungta
Vs. Secy. To the Government of Orissa [1962 Supp
approved.
State of U. P. v. Mohammed Nooh, [1958] S. C. R. 595,
distinguished.
JUDGMENT:
CIVIL APPELLATE, JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 383 of 1961.
Appeal ... pointed out in Madan Gopal
Rungta 's, case( 1) Mohammad Nooh 's case (2) was a special
case, which stands
relied upon an earlier decision in STATE OF U.P. v. MOHD. NOOH 1958 S.C.R. 595. It has to be pointed ... another Constitution Bench of this Court has observed that MOHD NOOH'S case (supra) was a case which depended on its own facts. Having
