that the dying
declaration being absolutely infirm, it cannot be placed reliance upon and
once the dying declaration is discarded, a serious dent is created ... dying
declaration is eminently vague is neither correct nor is it based on any
material on record. On the scanning of the dying declaration
that the
dying declaration being absolutely infirm, it cannot be placed reliance
upon and once the dying declaration is discarded, a serious dent is
created ... dying
declaration is eminently vague is neither correct nor is it based on
any material on record. On the scanning of the dying declaration
declared fit, the second dying declaration
was recorded by PW-27, Smt. Usha Chaturvedi, Sub-Divisional Magistrate.
This dying declaration is an elaborate one where ... putting her questions in the nature
of multiple choice questions. The prosecutrix gave her statement/dying
declaration through gestures and writings, Exhibit
multiple dying
declarations in Smt. Kamla v. State of Punjab (1993) 1 SCC 1, this Court
held as follows:
“A dying declaration should satisfy ... witnesses given in support of the other dying
declaration dated 6.11.1976. Finally, in the dying declaration before
a Magistrate on which possibly more reliance could
hospital; (ii)
Dying declaration (Ex.PW27/A) recorded by PW27 SDM Usha
Chaturvedi on 21.12.2012; and (iii) dying declaration ... dying declarations are true, voluntary and consistent.
Insofar as third dying declaration, this Court, in paras
(408) to (412) held that the dying declaration made
hospital; (ii) Dying declaration (Ex.PW-27/A)
recorded by PW-27 SDM Usha Chaturvedi on 21.12.2012;
and (iii) dying declaration ... dying declarations are true,
voluntary and consistent. Insofar as third dying
declaration, this Court, in paras (408) to (412) held
that the dying declaration made
declared fit, the second dying
declaration was recorded by PW-27, Smt. Usha Chaturvedi,
Sub-Divisional Magistrate. This dying declaration is an elaborate one
where ... putting her
questions in the nature of multiple choice questions. The prosecutrix
gave her statement/dying declaration through gestures and writings,
Exhibit
were
admittedly false and could not be relied upon. If the dying
declaration has been recorded by the Executive Magistrate on 15.4.2000
in the Government ... Vijianagaram on 16.4.2000 could not be true.
The contents of the dying declaration dated 28.4.2000 being full of
contradiction do not inspire confidence.
14. Admittedly
peeled off with
reddish area with small multiple blister were
present on left knee joint, whole skin could
easily be removed.
10) The skin ... together.
The learned trial Judge scanning the nature of recording of
dying declaration, Exhibit-PC, opined that it was not
reliable and credible
Navtej Singh Johar vs Union Of India Ministry Of Law And ... on 6 September, 2018
