Bhattathirippad Vs. Trav. Go. Govt. Para No. 50-59
2. Proposition :- Mutually destructive pleas are not maintainable and the Complaint is therefore an abuse ... deficiency' under Consumer Protection Act 1986. Such pleas are mutually destructive
2006 12 SCC ( Steel Authority of India Ltd. Vs. Union of India
permissible for a party to take
alternative pleas, argued that taking mutually
destructive pleas was not permissible in law. He
referred
Claims, however, which are not adverse, and which are not, therefore, mutually destructive, admit of concurrent realization. Hence, there are several possible cases of duplicate
Annexure R-1 and the fault card are self contradictory and mutually
destructive.
5. Faced with
this situation Mr. Sharma on behalf of the respondent
prevent recourse to
more than one proceeding. Unless the proceedings are mutually destructive
- which in this case they are not - recourse to multiple proceedings
M/S Punjab Circket Association, Mohali vs Acit, Mohali on 12 September, 2019
आयकर अपील
held that a litigant is estopped from raising inconsistent and mutually destructive plea. Relying upon Development Agreement dated 01.05.2009, executed between Jaypee Infratech Limited
Kangra district. Both
these pleas are self contradictory and mutually destructive. Violation if any is of the provisions of the
Motor Vehicles
submitted that the Corporate Debtor
cannot be allowed to raise a mutually destructive plea in view of the fact
that it has deposited TDS towards
respondent No.2 the forest corporation is self
contradictory and mutually destructive. In this behalf
original certificate given by the Competent Authority Annexure ... Goel
had no answer as to why this self contradictory and mutually destructive stand
is there on the part of his client.
12. There
