2009 2
compelled to undergo Narco Analysis test without her
consent and also to declare that the Narco Analysis test is
injurious to health ... conditions,
he was not subjected to narco analysis and therefore there
is no reason to presume that narco analysis would be
conducted on the petitioners
alleged assault was not quite clear from the case diary and
even from the narco analysis report, I specifically ascertained
those details from the prosecution ... kitchen strongly indicate a
case of homicide.
2) The scientific reports like brain finger printing
test report, narco analysis report etc., prove
involvement of accused
compel the petitioner to undergo narco analysis without assuring the petitioner as well as this Court that narco analysis is totally harmless and the same ... principle laid down in Nandini Satpathy's case has no application to narco analysis, which is a scientific test conducted during investigation. A Division
video cassettes available at
FSL, Bangalore in various cases of the Narco
Analysis tests, was drawn up by me in the presence
of the independent ... none
of these 3 tapes or of any other Narco analysis tests
in other cases, as spoken to by the above mentioned
officials
prosecution to prove its case beyond
reasonable doubt. The technique such as polygraph test and
narco analysis test would be helpful technology for the
investigating ... their innocence."
22. In the present case also, the petitioner wanted to subject
himself to Narco Analysis Test which according to the learned
counsel
conduct further
investigation in the "Sr. Abhaya Case" pursuant to the
narco analysis test reports. The learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, observing that ... further
investigation based on the narco analysis test report
and to file a progress report before court. The learned
Magistrate went wrong in extracting certain
view that it may be a case of suicide. Finally, the
suspects were subjected to Narco Analysis and apparently, based on the
informations so extracted ... trial of the accused by media and
the unreliability of Narco Analysis. The said daily is controlled by the
Church, to which the accused belonged
subject PW1 to PW3 to Narco
Analysis Test or Polygraph Test, to prove the defense case. The
petitioner herein is the 1st accused ... Narco Analysis Test.
7. In so far as the question as to whether a person shall
be directed to subject himself for Narco Analysis Test
report in the media that the accused in this case were
being subjected to Narco analysis test. He contacted the
Bishop's house ... spoke of in his chief examination, occurred after the
Narco analysis. We cannot but notice that A1 is not being
tried for the illicit relationship
report in the media that the accused in this case were
being subjected to Narco analysis test. He contacted the
Bishop's house ... spoke of in his chief examination, occurred after the
Narco analysis. We cannot but notice that A1 is not being
tried for the illicit relationship
