SELVIs case, a three Judge Bench of this Court was
considering whether involuntary administration of certain scientific
techniques like narco- analysis, polygraph examination ... SELVIs case (supra), a three Judge Bench of this Court was
considering whether involuntary administration of certain scientific
techniques like narco- analysis, polygraph examination
conduct Narco
Analysis Test, Brain Mapping Test and Polygraph Test upon him
from the Forensic Directorate, Gujarat State.
Brief facts of the case are that ... circumstances of the case, this
Court is clearly of the opinion that when the petitioner never
requested for Narco Analysis Test, Brain Mapping Test
Selvi case) had allowed the petition on the ground that the judgment in Selvi case pertains to Narco Analysis, polygraph test, and brain mapping. Drawing ... Constitution of India and it fall par with the test like narco- analysis, polygraph examination and the Brain Electrical Activation Profile (BEAP) tests, therefore, impermissible
usefulness of a narco analysis test has
been doubted. Moreover, the Supreme Court has held that
3
administration of narco analysis test violates the right ... petitioner should undergo a narco analysis test. Selvi (supra) is of the
view that, compulsory administration of narco analysis test violates
the right against self
CONSEQUENTLY ALLOW
THIS PETITION BY DIRECTING THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO
UNDERGO NARCO ANALYSIS TEST AS PRAYED FOR.
THIS CRL.P COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS ... polygraph test and Narco
Analysis test on respondent No.2 who is arrayed as accused No.1
in the said case. The said application
Mohd.Samir was subjected to polygraph, brain mapping
and Narco analysis test conducted by PW15 Dr.Malini
Subramanyam. The Report thereof was considered to
Gaikwad ... argued by the
learned counsel for appellants / accused that the case of the
prosecution is purely based on circumstantial evidence and
the prosecution
Selvi case) had allowed the petition on the ground that the judgment in Selvi case pertains to Narco Analysis, polygraph test, and brain mapping. Drawing ... Constitution of India and it fall par with the test like narco- analysis, polygraph examination and the Brain Electrical Activation Profile (BEAP) tests, therefore, impermissible
Mohd.Samir was subjected to polygraph, brain mapping
and Narco analysis test conducted by PW15 Dr.Malini
Subramanyam. The Report thereof was considered to
Gaikwad ... argued by the
learned counsel for appellants / accused that the case of the
prosecution is purely based on circumstantial evidence and
the prosecution
public outcry and instead, chose to and went
ahead with the false case against the appellant.
(xvi) The investigating agency with the help ... hostel on that night to Narco Analysis test despite orders of Court, creates
any amount of doubt on the case of the prosecution.
(xvii) There
directed that the
accused be subjected to varous scientific tests viz. Narco Analysis,
Brain Mapping and Polygraph, etc. so that the truth of the matter ... case of
(3 of 6)
[CRLR-679/2017]
Smt. Selvi & Ors. vs. State of Karnataka, AIR 2010 SC 1974,
the narco analysis and other
