part of the
collegium as of today or, if an NJAC is to be constituted today, could be a
member thereof. With utmost respect ... member
of the collegium; His Lordship will be a member of the NJAC if it is
constituted today. Therefore, there is a manifest conflict
part of the collegium as of today or, if an NJAC is to be constituted
today, could be a member thereof. With utmost respect ... member of the collegium; His Lordship will be a
member of the NJAC if it is constituted today. Therefore, there is a
manifest conflict
recent verdict rendered by the
Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in NJAC case[(2016)
5 SCC 1 (Supreme Court Advocates-On-Record Association ... members of the
body. If the aforesaid principles are made applicable to
NJAC, the natural outcome would be that a valid meeting
of NJAC must
Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record
Association) also known as NJAC case, but also to the
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court ... fact that the dictum of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in NJAC case cannot be considered to be a
precedent having force
signed by
ANITA MALHOTRA
Date: 2017.01.17
Appointment Commission case, popularly known as NJAC
case is void ab initio on various grounds ... India
purportedly for the reason that His Lordship’s judgment in the NJAC case is
“void ab initio”;
9
b) A declaration “that the lead
Another v. UOI , reported at JT 2015 (10) 1, commonly known as NJAC
case, the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in the context ... Minister in charge of Law and Justice, as a Member of the NJAC,
as contemplated under Article 124A(1) , in the matter of
appointment
reported in (2016) 5 SCC 1 is hereinafter referred to as the NJAC Act case. In Paragraph 518.2 of NJAC Act case, supra, referred ... aforesaid factors.
13. The petitioner also cited paragraph 539 of the NJAC Act case, supra, set out herein below:
539. In the Supreme Court Advocates
reputation and dignity. The 99th Constitution Amendment Act and the NJAC Act have not taken note of the privacy concerns of an individual. This ... submitted by the learned Attorney General that the proceedings of NJAC will be completely transparent and any one can have access to information that
suggestions made by
the Supreme Court in its judgment in the NJAC case; so too the
matters which the Supreme Court in the NJAC case ... seeking review of the judgments in
Judges-2, Judges-3 and the NJAC cases, particularly taking
notice of the fact that petitions seeking review
Justice K.S.Puttaswamy(Retd) And Anr. vs Union Of India And Ors. on 24
