serial no. 3513 it is indicated "FEMALE OUT OF UP, Normalised Marks below Vertical Cut-Off OC of 193.8763".
Learned counsel for petitioner ... impugned list i.e. "FEMALE OUT OF UP, Normalised Marks below Vertical Cut-Off OC of 193.8763" so far as it pertains
illegal
and without jurisdiction and consequently set aside the
"Normalised Marks" merit list of and direct the
Respondents to re-evaluate and publish ... each carrying a maximum of 25 marks (aggregating to 75
marks). Also, the marking pattern over the performance spectrum in
the case of men candidates
words "marks awarded" or "marks obtained in the written papers" refers only to the actual marks awarded by the examiner ... marks awarded on moderation become the final marks of the candidate. In fact Rule 20(3) specifically refers to the 'marks finally awarded
other candidates based
upon the marks while in the written examination, the marks of one of
- 10 -
the other candidates will be normalized ... evident from Annexure-4 annexed to the writ petition that
the normalised marks of candidates category wise has been
furnished as :-
Category Normalised marks Date
list has been declared on 02.3.2020, wherein the petitioner obtained 149.5% normalized marks, which is more than the last selected candidate under the General (Female ... female out of the State of U.P. and her normalised marks is below the vertical cut-off marks of other category. The second respondentconsidered
also
dissatisfied with the denial of the information related to the normalisation of
marks of the last three candidates figuring in the merit list ... Appellant is
advised to pursue her grievances related to the normalisation of marks before the
appropriate forum.
The appeal is disposed of accordingly.
Saroj Punhani
respondent to publish final rank list after carrying out
the normalisation of raw marks as laid down in Ext.P5
Information Bulletin.
ii) declare ... mentioned in Ext.P5
bulletin only after carrying out normalisation of raw
marks obtained into percentile score as instructed in
Ext.P5 bulletin
arriving at the present basis of marking and decided to grant
credit marks up to 30 for the marks obtained in the academic
examinations ... academic marks is
granted by reducing the percentage of marks secured to a unit of 30
employing a normalisation method. These are all matters, which
applies a 'Normalisation Formula' where examination is held in
multiple shifts. After the formula is applied, final marks of a candidate may
increase ... reduction in their marks. Thus, Respondents may be directed
to disclose in each exam the values used in the Normalisation Formula,
wherever applicable.
5. Having
petitioners is that, the method
of normalisation, which is applied by the respondents qua the marks of the
candidates, has been carried
