filling in the application, it appears that
50% marks were assigned for oral interviews. Upon careful
perusal of the additional affidavit-in-reply filed ... petitioner had
no opportunity to take an exception to 50% marks assigned
for oral interviews. We find considerable force in the
argument of the learned
which voices a far
and balanced criticism of the oral interview method:
"The oral test of the interview has been much
criticized ... interview test. This becomes a serious matter
when the marks assigned to oral test constitute a
high proportion of the total marks in the
competition
Government of Maharashtra, oral interviews were
conducted and marks were assigned to such oral
interview. Since petitioner has secured highest marks
and there ... case of the
petitioner, it is true that, the marks assigned in the oral
::: Downloaded on - 11/05/2015
clinicals. In respect of Medicine, the theory paper was
assigned 120 marks and the orals ... paper was assigned 20 marks. The
practicals and clinicals were assigned 100 marks. In respect of Surgery also,
the same marks were assigned. The Internal
support of this submission, the
learned counsel invited my attention to various oral evidence led by the
parties.
20. In so far as the finding ... attention to various parts of the
oral evidence. He submits that the claimant had not assigned video
and satellite rights in the said proposed film
Furniture Block, Kirti Nagar, New Delhi-110015, he was
assigned the work of telephone operator of all the establishments during the
period ... Noida, Ghaziabad, UP by an oral order. He served at Noida
till 2nd April, 1998. The management stopped assigning any work to him
and also
Speaking to Minutes Order
WP.2608.2014.Oral Judgment.doc
these financial institutions came to be assigned and taken over by
Respondent ... Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
WP.2608.2014.Oral Judgment.doc
financial institutions and those are admitted by the Petitioners
want of provisions, has maintained the unreasoned order without
assigning any specific reason inspite of oral and in writing submission
so made by the learners ... pupils/students/learners. In the present case, both the
Authorities have not assigned any specific reason by deciding and/or
not considering individual case
proper selection process conducted by the TNPSC and the rank assigned to the candidates is in order.
15. The issues which falls for consideration ... recorded a finding that the oral test was the method of assessment as per the notification and the oral test conducted for about 16 days
advanced in the present case that the selection committee
ought to have assigned separate marks for the different faculties
of the candidates concerned, namely, intelligence ... maintain proper record of the oral test in respect
of each candidate and marks must preferably be assigned under
each head considered to be relevant
