other storage media much less any CD in which the original
audio recording in question was copied by the FSL was supplied ... proved. As mentioned above, the original mobile phone
could not be played.
9.9. Thus, the original audio recording could not be proved in the present
being used by Ashu Khan. Allegedly this memory card contained
original audio recordings done by Ashu Khan for demand of bribe by
the accused.
Judgment ... audio
clip and claimed that it could be voice of accused or Rajeev Pandey.
These audio clippings mentioned above were the audio
recordings contained
examined the audio files contained in the pen drive and no alteration in the audio
recordings were found. Also, the audio files in the mobile ... requisite conditions for
admissibility of the audio recordings in this case were fulfilled. The audio
recordings of the conversations between the accused and PW4, though
issuance of audio recording device to this witness.
Importantly, the witness also admitted that he did not
preserve the original recording in the recording device ... Jain. The witness admitted that he also did not
seize the original audio recording device. When the witness
was asked as to existence
voice sample was recorded in
FSL, Rohini on 06.08.2015. Sample voice of the accused was recorded in original
audio cassette marked as SVNK ... electronic evidence is concerned, admittedly the original audio-video
recording could never be recovered in the present case. Therefore, this part of
evidence
hear
any audio recording, therefore, he cannot state whether the transcript
Mark P-18/2 contained true account of the audio recording ... with the questioned audio
recording.
13.2. Also, the voice sample of the accused did not match with the questioned
audio recording and the voice sample
been furnished by Karnail Singh who had
prepared the CD. Original audio/video recording device was not sent to
FSL for analysis. Reliance has been ... Kumari
(PW26) with respect to demand of bribe, was the audio/video recording
contained in CD Ex. P1 and its transcript
subsequently using the original recorded tape,
without materially altering the contents of the video.
(iii) The lip sync is matching in audio and video ... recorded in the VCD and VHS cassette had matched with their voice as
recorded in the video cassettes covering their interviews.
Investigation has further disclosed
original recording
was made and what was the original source of recording such as mobile instruments, personal digital assistant, blackberry device, digital recorder ... audio can be authenticated only after examining the actual recording devices [carrying the source audio files], which were used to record the original conversation
Central Bureau Of Investigation vs K.V.Srinivasa Prasad on 9 December, 2020
IN THE
