parties to
refer "any disputes under the agreements" to arbitration, otiose and
nullity. Such an interpretation is clearly contrary to the object ... said clause, i.e. the arbitration agreement would become
completely otiose/irrelevant, which certainly could not have been the
intention of the parties.
Page
settled that an interpretation which will render any part of
the statute otiose is to be avoided. Reliance is placed in this
regard
proviso to lay down the forum of
appeal cannot be rendered otiose or nugatory by referring to Section ... resorted to which would render a part of a provision
otiose. In fact, in Dwarka Prasad vs. Dwarka Das Saraf [(1976) 1 SCC
128] [relied
settled that an interpretation which will render any part of
the statute otiose is to be avoided. Reliance is placed in this
regard
settled that an interpretation which will render any part of
the statute otiose is to be avoided. Reliance is placed in this
regard
render
the statutory provision otiose. In a recent decision of a three-Judge
Bench of this Court in Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited ... That would render the legislative scheme and
intention behind the stated provision otiose.
16. The respondent had relied on the decision of this Court
Pareshkumar Jaykarbhai Brahmbhatt vs State Of Gujarat on 15 December, 2017
Author: J.B.Pardiwala
Vadodara Shaheri Jilla Khedut Mandal ... vs Vadodara Municipal Corporation Thro' ... on 15 July, 2014
Hasvantbhai Chhanubhai Dalal vs Adesinh Mansinh Raval on 12 April, 2019
Equivalent citations: AIRONLINE 2019
same is making the entire Section 69 of the
CGST Act nugatory / otiose.
33. It was submitted that the provisions of the
Section ... provisions
of the Section 69 of the CGST Act would get
redundant / otiose.
37. It was submitted by the learned Advocate
General that even otherwise
