proceedings or in collateral proceedings between the same parties, rewrite the overruled judgement. Even if it was a decision on a pure question ... first judgement and, curiously, Mr. Justice Ajit Kumar Sengupta, sitting in the Division Bench, wrote a second time, a judgement which was already overruled
claim classification as Ayurvedic Medicine. This order of
the Tribunal was overruled by this Court in the case of Amrutanjan Ltd. vs. CCE
reported ... Unfortunately, the Assistant Commissioner and
the Commissioner (Appeals) relied on the overruled judgement of the CEGAT, because
the judgment of this Court was not available
dated 4th May 2015, that the reliance was placed
before on overruled judgements like the case of Pasupuleti
Venkateswarulu Vs. Motor and General Traders reported
Kalifullah v. M.Abdul Khader and Another (2013 (2) CTC 839) overruled the judgement in Jabar Maideen v. Vallam Jumma Pallivasal Committee (cited supra ... Bench judgement, it is crystal clear that the judgement in A.K.Kalifullah v. M.Abdul Khader and Another (cited supra) stands impliedly overruled
strenuously
contended that the Adjudicating Authority has erroneously relied upon the
overruled Judgement 'Sesh Nath Singh & Anr.' Vs. 'Baidyabati Sheoraphuli
Cooperative
favour. In so deciding, the
Pune Bench, inter alia, relied on the judgement of the Hon'ble Bombay High
Court in CIT Vs. Shakuntala ... Mohammed Hussein Merchant [(2005) 275 ITR 231 (Bom.)]. As
the later judgement overruling the earlier judgement was not brought to the
notice of the Pune
consideration that the judgement of Raman Iron
Foundry (supra) stood overruled by the judgement of M/s HM
Kamaluddin Ansari and Co vs Union ... judgement of Raman Iron
Foundry (supra). Since the judgement of Gangotri is completely
based upon Raman Iron Foundry (supra) which judgement
already stood overruled
Jindal Stainless Ltd (supra) cannot be construed
21
to have overruled the impugned judgement and order of the learned
Single Judge dated June ... Jindal Steel
Ltd (supra) and all other judgements that follow such
pronouncements, the impugned judgement and order dated June 24,
2013 does not survive
Jindal Stainless Ltd (supra) cannot be construed
21
to have overruled the impugned judgement and order of the learned
Single Judge dated June ... Jindal Steel
Ltd (supra) and all other judgements that follow such
pronouncements, the impugned judgement and order dated June 24,
2013 does not survive
Jindal Stainless Ltd (supra) cannot be construed
21
to have overruled the impugned judgement and order of the learned
Single Judge dated June ... Jindal Steel
Ltd (supra) and all other judgements that follow such
pronouncements, the impugned judgement and order dated June 24,
2013 does not survive
