said para of this
affidavit. It is very disturbing for us to note that the respondent No.2
failed to give para-wise reply ... reply affidavit. Therefore, we direct the respondent No.2 to give para-
wise reply of the allegations/averments made by the applicant within a
period
Waris Chemicals Pvt Ltd vs Uttar Pradesh Pollution Control Board on 16 January, 2023
Author
Dehat. 15
days' time was allowed to submit its reply but no reply was submitted
hence on 19.11.2019, final order was passed, imposing environmental ... hearing on
31.07.2020 when it was disposed of as infructuous.
22. Para-wise reply given by UPPCB in para 4 of reply is as under
same as already
discussed and mentioned above.
Replies by respondents 7, 10 and 11:
18. Replies dated 17.08.2023 have been field by respondent ... repeating the same. In reply of respondent 11, substantial part
is similar to other replies. There is separate para-wise reply also. However,
the central
Proponent, a reply affidavit
dated 08.04.2021 has been filed, where-in para-wise reply has been given,
denying all the allegations made by the Appellant
mining through blasting operations subject such
conditions as prescribed by DGMS.
Para-wise reply to OA:
23. Insofar as the contents of Para ... mining through blasting operations subject such
conditions as prescribed by DGMS.
Para-wise reply to OA:
26. Insofar as the contents of Para
surface and
groundwater contamination."
6 Respondents are directed to submit para-wise reply/contention raised by
the applicant and to ensure the compliance
reply filed by the District Magistrate, Ludhiana is reproduced below:-
"Reply of Surabhi Malik, IAS, District Magistrate,
Ludhiana on behalf of the respondent ... have submitted the
reports. On the basis of above reports, para wise reply is as
follows:-
Sr. Information Reply
No. Sought
able to explain to us the contents of para
1
7 of the affidavit. The words 'litholog, phreatic aquifer, coalescence, aeolian
action, transmissivity, thick ... affidavit of the Central Ground Water Board is not a
para-wise reply to the allegations made in the Original Application nor
does it even
Board shall also address itself to the
observations made in para 13 of the order of the Tribunal dated
22.08.2022 and explain as to whether ... lakhs?
5. The affidavit of the Board shall also give a para-wise reply to the
averments made in the Original Application.
6. List
