Singh, Assistant Collector, Grade II (Tehsildar), Budhlada, then
order in parat patwar and parat sarkar should be in the same hand i.e.
by Sohan ... parat sarkar was not on the file. Parat
patwar was in the custody of the appellant. Parat sarkar was in the
office and for production
respondent
no.1 was there in the Parat Patwar and not in the Parat Sarkar, therefore,
the other three sisters were alienating the suit property ... respondent no.1-plaintiff is shown in the Parat Patwar but was
missing in the Parat Sarkar, which though is a copy of the said
called the "Parat
Sarkar". The "Parat Patwar" and the "Parat Sarkar" should
record the same entries but if, there ... material difference
between the "Parat Patwar" and the "Parat Sarkar", the
documents would be inherently unreliable. We have perused
copies produced
moved application (Annexure P-2) for additional
evidence alleging that Parat Patwar and Parat Sarkar of inheritance
mutation of Darka - sister of plaintiff ... respective
stands. Counsel for the petitioner, however, also submitted that Parat
Patwar and Parat Sarkar of another mutation of inheritance of Chandro are
also required
called the "Parat
Sarkar". The "Parat Patwar" and "Parat
Sarkar" should record the same entries but if,
there ... material difference between the
"Parat Patwar" and the "Parat Sarkar", the
documents would be inherently unreliable. We
have perused copies produced
Rule 27 CPC for producing the following documents:
Annexure P-1 Parat Sarkar in respect of mutation No. 5686.
Annexure P2 Copy of Jamabandi ... Appeal No. 3498 of 1985:
1. Whether Exhibit P28 Parat Patwar without production of Parat Sarkar carry any legal value to show the reasons
entry regarding "Chargah"
was still in existence in "Parat Sarkar, even in the jamabandi for
the year ... said persons have been
entered in the "Parat Patwari" as well as "Parat Sarkar" by the
concerned Patwari just to give
relying upon "parat patwar". In appeal, the lower
Appellate Court gave credence to the "parat sarkar" and noticing the
fact that ... placed. Report of the local commissioner is based upon the parat
patwar and parat sarkar. It was objected to but the objections remained
undecided. Even
maintained in the office of Sadar Kanungo known as Parat Sarkar. It
is further argued that presumption attached to entries in the Jamabandis
relied upon ... appellant gets sufficiently rebutted in view of entries in
Jamabandis (Parat Sarkar) maintained by the Sadar Kanungo on behalf of
Collector of the District. According
copies of Parat Patwar whereas Ex.P19 is the
copy of Parat Sarkar. These documents show that appellant Jai Narain
Patwari has already entered
