pre-emption
emption law prevailing in Oudh. In the second
place, so far as the pre-emption
emption law in the Punjab is
concerned ... while
dealing with a claim of pre-emption
emption and as already stated,
the right of pre-emption
emption being a right of substitution
pre-emption
emption law prevailing in Oudh. In the second
place, so far as the pre-emption
emption law in the Punjab is
concerned ... while
dealing with a claim of pre-emption
emption and as already stated,
the right of pre-emption
emption being a right of substitution
pre-emption
emption law in Punjab is concerned, one rule is
firmly settled that the right of pre
pre-emption
emption is a right ... while dealing with a claim of
pre-emption
emption and, as already stated, the right of pre-
pre
emption being a right of substitution
denied the claim
of the pre-emptor with specific objection against the claim of partial pre-
emption and also that they are co-sharer with ... pre-emption
the question of title in respect of the title deeds rarely come up for
adjudication as the right of pre-emption
suit is
bad for partial pre-emption. It was also claimed that the plaintiff has no right
to pre-empt.
1.5 The plaintiff while filing ... entitled to
pre-empt the entire sale?"
3.4 The Supreme Court held that the tenant is entitled to decree of
pre-emption with respect
superior right of pre
pre-emption.
emption. On these
averments, the suit for possession by way of pre
pre-emption was filed.
3. The defendants ... further raised the plea of partial pre
pre-emption,
emption,
contending that the plaintiff could not pre-empt
pre empt the sale as alleged
framed:
"1.
1. Whether the plaintiffs have superior right to pre
pre-empt
empt the sale
in question against the vendee--defendants ... PHHC:018028
B. Whether the suit is bad being partial pre
pre-emption? OPD
C. Whether the suit has been filed by the plaintiffs
Sarup vs. Munshi18 there was a decree of
pre-emption against the defendant-appellants who had
bought the property from the co-defendants ... that there can be no partial pre-
emption because pre-emption is the substitution
of the pre-emptor in place of the vendee
others
and that the abatement could, in any event, be only partial
and would not affect the continuance of the appeal by the
surviving appellants ... clear law that there can be no partial pre- emption
because pre-emption is the substitution of the pre-emptor in
place of the vendee
beacons of justice in the case
at hand, particularly when the pre-emption application stands on
fragile ground, having been filed without fulfilling the
fundamental ... contention regarding petitioner's right to pre-empt land. While
the petitioner seeks pre-emption rights across three separate
deeds, petitioner deposited an amount
