Volume 1 Supreme Court Cases
page 470 (Union of India v. Popular Construction Company (supra)
in relation thereto was also considered. The difference between Section ... Zubida Begum (supra) considered Hukumdev (supra) and Mukri
Gopalan (supra). Popular Construction Company (supra) was also
considered therein.
Smt. Sajida Begum (supra) considered Seth Banshidhar
decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Popular Construction Company , is confined to Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The learned Judge ... view of the decision of Supreme Court in the case of Popular Construction Company (supra) where the Supreme Court specifically held that because
Apex Court in
the case of Union of India Vs. Popular
Construction Company, reported in (2001) 8 SCC
470. It was contended that thus ... wherein the
judgment of Union of India Vs. Popular
Construction Company (supra) is followed and
applied.
5.1 It was contended that it is settled
proviso".
Their Lordships referred to Union of India -vs- Popular
Construction Company, 2001(8) SCC 470 which case
relentlessly emphasizes the words ... apposite to immediately recall the dicta of Union of India -vs-
Popular Construction Company, (2001) 8 SCC 470. We can do
no better than reiterate
Supreme Court in Union of India v/s. Popular
Construction Company (supra), Mr. Kadam has submitted that if this
Court proceeds to hold that section ... paragraph 10 of its
decision in Union of India v/s. Popular Construction Company
(Supra) referring to the decision of its Constitution Bench in Vidya
judgment of
the Supreme court in Union of India v. Popular Construction
Company , (2001) 8 SCC 470. The Special Leave Petition
against this judgment bearing ... nothing but exclusionary. The Supreme Court in Union of
India v. Popular Construction Company , AIR 2001 SC 4010 while
analyzing Section
displace the applicability of Section 5 .
63. In M/s. Popular Construction Company 's case (supra), the Supreme Court was considering whether the time
Appeal No.24 of 2011
iv) Union of India Versus Popular Construction
Company 2001(8) SCC 470.
v) Singh Enterprises Versus Commissioner Central
Excise ... follows:-
i) 2001(8) SCC 470 Union of India Versus Popular
Construction Company.
ii) 2008(3) SCC 70 Singh Enterprises Versus
Commissioner Central Excise
Mulchandani. We may also mention that though the decision in Popular Construction Company is rendered after the decision in Pushpa P.Mulchandani 's case ... Mulchandani 's case are fully supported by the decision in Popular Construction Company 's case. It is impossible to subscribe to the view
subject of interpretation in Union of India v/s.
M/s. Popular Construction Company, 2001 (8) SCC
470. It was held by the Apex Court ... came up for consideration before various
High Courts. The observation in Popular Construction
Company that the period of limitation prescribed under
Section 34 was absolute
