State Of Goa vs M/S Praveen Enterprises on 4 July, 2011
Equivalent citations: AIR 2011 SUPREME COURT ... 15337 of 2009]
State of Goa ... Appellant
Vs.
Praveen Enterprises ... Respondent
J U D G M E N T
R.V.RAVEENDRAN, J.
Leave granted
Shipping Corporation of India Limited [1] and
State of Goa v. Praveen Enterprises [2], and came to hold that the
arbitral proceedings in respect ... concept of limitation as has been explained in Praveen
Enterprises (supra), the demand made by the appellant therein by letter
dated 17.4.2006 quantifying
relied upon
the case of State of Goa vs. M/s Praveen Enterprises, Civil
Appeal No. 4987/2011 order dated 04.07.2011. Para ... placed on the case
of State of Goa vs. M/s Praveen Enterprises (2012) SCC 581 to
stress the point that when an Arbitrator
Shipping Corporation of India Limited [1] and
State of Goa v. Praveen Enterprises [2], and came to hold that the
arbitral proceedings in respect ... concept of limitation as has been explained in Praveen
Enterprises (supra), the demand made by the appellant therein by letter
dated 17.4.2006 quantifying
Supreme Court of India State of
Goa versus Praveen Enterprises (2012) 12 SCC 581.
12. It is further the case of the Respondents that ... Supreme Court of India in State of Goa Vs. Praveen
Enterprises , (2012) 12 SCC 581. Taking recourse of the above judgment,
Ld. Counsel
Court
and has mentioned that the same is an extract from Praveen
Enterprises case law being law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme
Court ... State of Goa Vs. Praveen Enterprises reported in (2012)
12 SCC 581, but the extract is actually from Voltas Limited Vs.
Rolta India Limited case
other words, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Praveen Enterprises held that Section 21 will operate as the
reckoning date in cases where limitation ... raised. After noticing Praveen
Enterprises case, Delhi High Court also noticed that Hon'ble Supreme Court
has observed in Praveen Enterprises case that Section
2001 ) dated 4 December 2001 and State of Goa v. Praveen
Enterprises 2011(3) Arb.L.R. 209 are inapplicable as the facts are
::: Downloaded ... Moreover, the decision of the Apex Court in the matter of Praveen
Enterprises (supra) would be applicable to the present facts as the
respondent
down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the oft-
quoted Praveen Enterprises case being State of Goa Vs. Praveen
Enterprises reported ... Praveen Enterprises case,
wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court, after analysing Section 21 of A and C Act
and Section 3 of the Limitation
Cream (P) Ltd.5 and State of Goa v. Praveen Enterprises 6.
10.2 Second, the date of receipt of notice is also relevant to
determine ... note this Court’s decision in
State of Goa v. Praveen Enterprises (supra) wherein it was held that
the claims and disputes raised
