Shiv Prasad
• 171 ITR 698 (Alla.) CIT v. Goyal Private Family Specific
Trust
• 297 ITR 99 (Alla.) CIT v. Mahendra Kumar Bansal
Allahabad High Court in the case of CIT
vs. Goyal Private Family Specific Trust , 171 ITR 698 (Alld.) has held under
para ... held by this Court in the case of Goyal Private Family Specific
Trust (supra,) we are of the considered opinion that merely because
filed beyond the prescribed period.
In the case of Goyal Private Family Specific Trust [1988] 171 ITR
698, this court has held that the order ... held by this court in the case of Goyal Private Family Specific
Trust [1988] 171 ITR 698, we are of the considered opinion that
merely
reliance on the following judicial pronouncements:
( i) CIT vs. Goyal Private Family Specific Trust [1998] 171 ITR
698 (All)
( ii) CIT vs. Arvind Jewellers ... Allahabad High Court rendered in the case of Goyal
Private Family Specific Trust (Supra). In this case, it is noted by Hon'ble
Allahabad
contended that the office premises in question
is a private property of Janak Specific Family
Trust and said trust has created mortgage by
deposit ... aforesaid proprietary
concern of Janak Specific Family Trust has
purchased the property from Patel Specific Family
Trust is also on record. Thus, from the aforesaid
books.
iii) In the case of CIT v Goyal Private family Specific Trust
1988, 171 ITR 698 701-202 Alld, it was held that
Goyal Private F amily Specific Trust, 1 71 ITR 6 98 (Alld.) has held
under p a ra n o. 12 as unde ... Court in the case of Go yal Private Family
Specific Trust (supra ), we ar e of th e considered opinio n
that merely becaus
established. The distinction between a private and a public trust is
that whereas in the former, the beneficiaries are specific individuals, in
the latter, they ... trusts for charitable
purposes, and indeed public trusts and charitable trusts may be considered
in general as synonymous expressions. In private trusts the beneficial
interest
trust on 05.12.1974 as
public trust. The plaintiff has been making appropriate
representations to the authorities concerned to treat the trust
as a private trust ... tests to determine whether a trust is private or public
trust:
(a) The objects of trust.
(b) Beneficiaries are specific individual or group of public
Whether the first respondent / plaintiff Trust is a Public Trust or
Private Trust?
ii. Whether any specific endowment had been arranged for the appellant /
fourth ... Trust is a public religious Trust.
iii. The Lower Court ought not to have held that the first respondent /
plaintiff Trust is a Private Trust