Case Dairy cannot be made
available as it is a privileged document. The charges levelled against the
applicants are for official misconduct committed by them ... them, that
cannot be denied contending that the Case Diaries are privileged documents.
It is further submitted there is no privilege as such
bank statement of the complainant is only one of the documents filed by Shri Sudhakar Rao in support of the complaint. Therefore, it cannot ... process of the Court since such a statement is not privileged document disclosure of which can be withheld from a criminal court. Therefore, it would
affairs of
state, they cannot be withheld by state as privileged documents under Evidence Act , but
has to disclose under RTI Act , subject only ... privilege mentioned in Section 8(1)(c) is Parliamentary privilege, and if the information
sought might cause breach of Privilege of parliament or assembly, that
well as to the Surveyor and
relevant documents were also provided to the Surveyor. The Surveyor
demanded for balance sheets, log book ... Excavator, maintenance
records, operation locations. As the balance sheet is privileged
document, therefore, the balance sheet was not provided to the
Surveyor. The Surveyor assessed
allegations constituting criminal offence and bank statement of complainant was only one document filed by Sudhakar in support of his complaint. The same ... complainant through process of court since such statement was not a privileged document disclosure of which could be withheld from criminal court. Thus
documents prepared or to be kept by a prospecting mine
operator but prospecting a mine or mineral is a privilege conferred by
the State ... arise especially, when they are public documents. By disclosure of
such information, no privilege or business interests of the petitioner are
affected. On the other
certain
classes of documents which are necessarily required to be protected, e.g. Cabinet
Minutes, documents concerning the national safety, documents which affect
diplomatic relations ... Court would ordinarily uphold Government's claim of
privilege. However, even these documents have to be tested against the basic guiding
principle which
forged
documents regarding his transfer does not stand conclusively proved".
11. Accordingly, a penalty of withholding of three (3) sets of
Privilege passes ... supply of documents
to the applicant. Ultimately, a lenient view was taken and
minor penalty of stoppage of three (3) sets of Privilege passes
find that the applicant
had sought adjournment to produce certain documents and adduce more
documents on record. Paragraphs 13 and 14 of the report read ... compulsory retired as he had taken
Privilege pass in the name of his nephew Sarvesh as documents
provided by the office
report. Ex.R-5 is policy document of Standard Fire and Special Perils Policy. Ex.R-6 is privileged report prepared by Yashwinder Goyal ... record. Similarly, we have also examined other documents Ex.R-15 to Ex.R-26 relied upon by OP. Ex.R-27 terms and conditions
