matter was carried in appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council; but the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council refused to interfere with ... Scheme as finally sanctioned by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council provided for the administration of the properties of the temple to be carries
high an authority as the Judicial Committed of the Privy Council in Sasiman Chowdhurain v. Shib Narain ... same warning was again reiterated by the Judicial Committee of Privy Council in Shalig Ram v. Charanjit
eventually decided the mater relying upon the decision given by the Privy Council in Perpetual Executors and Trustees Association of Australia Ltd. v. Commissioner ... appeared on behalf of the revenue, heavily relied upon the Privy Council decisions in Attorney-General v. Boden and Perpetual Executors and Trustees Association
Court in such cases is no longer open to question. The Privy Council in Brij Indar Singh v. Kanshi ... sufficient cause within the meaning of Section 5 ."
The Privy Council after quoting the above passages observed that "these citations seem to show
phrase 'Hindu undivided family'", as observed by the Privy Council in Kalyanji Vithaldas v. Commissioner of Income-tax 1 "is used ... Nagpur High Court which were quoted with approval by the Privy Council in Anant Bhikkappa Patil v. Shankar Ramchandra Patil 1 :
"We regard
respectfully followed those decisions. But I find that both the Privy Council and the Supreme Court have taken a view contrary to that taken ... arriving at this decision followed a previous decision of the Privy Council reported In Mungul Pershad v. Grija Kant, 8 Ind App 123 (PC). This
relied on the decision of the Privy Council in Manzur Hasan v. Muhammad Zaman 47 Allahabad 151 and argued that this decision supported his contention ... Bombay High Court which was adversely commented upon by the Privy Council in this decision. That decision of the Bombay High Court was given
with this point, we must refer to one decision of the Privy Council on which the strongest reliance was placed by Mr. J. P. Shah ... assessee and the revenue, therefore, carried the matter before the Privy Council. Before the Privy Council, two questions were canvassed, namely, whether the Income
Glossary of
Judicial & Revenue Terms, the decision of the Privy Council
in Ranchordas v. Parvatibai(ll) and the decision of the
Bombay High Court ... together. It is true that as early as in 1899 the
Privy Council in Runchordas Vandrawandas C. and others v.
Parvatibhai and others (Supra) declared
approval must be strictly proved".
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council pointed out in Man Mohan Das v. Janki Prasad ... business. There are at least two decision, one of the Privy Council. and the other of the Calcutta High Court, which clearly show inferentially that
