upheld
because Government had retrospective amended the promotion rule so that
promotees could just go into promotion quota by sheer seniority rather than
by selection ... position
when the quota rule breaks down.
Quota rule has not broken down :
On the question of breakdown of quota rule, except the lethargy
Executive Order, 50% of the quota
was provided for direct recruits and the balance 50% quota by
promotion was sub-divided prescribing 35% for diploma ... follows :-
"..whether for promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer in the 50% promotion quota reserved for the
person possessing degree in Electrical Engineering
scale as and
when a vacancy (except a vacancy in the promotion quota)
arose therein and no one senior to him was available for
that ... Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 clearly
indicate that there is a process of selection in the matter
of filling up the promotion quota.
The argument
first time to make recommendations for appointment being accorded by promotion in the promotion quota of 1988-89 onwards and ultimately vide order dated ... Pramila Surana was given promotion of year 1992-93 and Shri Doongardan Charan was given promotion of quota of 1988-89 by merit.
41. With
treated as Assistant Commandants in Group-A
Class-I within the promotion quota of the 40% from group B
to group A, it was wrong ... quota quota recr-ies be filled
uit to be by promo-
left dive- tion.
during rted
the from
year. Dr quota
to promo-
tion quota
appointment in the
Indian Administrative Service. The promotion quota of non-
cadre officers to cadre posts which was 50 prior to October ... Central Government: (b) the existence of a vacancy in
the promotion quota of cadre officers was not a condition
pre-requisite for making an appointment
quota would be filled up by promotion of Junior Engineers (Civil) and 10% posts under the promotion quota to be filled up from amongst Junior ... quota would be filled up by promotion of Junior Engineers (Civil) and 10% posts under the promotion quota to be filled up from amongst Junior
direct recruitment and by promotion, respectively.
The 1/3 promotion quota was again bifurcated into 24% for promotees
with qualification of ten (10) years’ service ... graduates in
the matter of fixation of such quota. The result of fixation of
quota of promotion for each of the two categories of
Supervisors
under 50 per cent quota of meritcumseniority. The
rules providing 25 per cent quota for out of turn promotion
being in place ... details of
any further promotion or appointment made after 2004 to 2008.
The out of turn promotion quota having been culled out only
India, provides for recruitment by both direct
recruitment and promotion and where promotion quota of any
earlier year could not be filled ... regard to the recommendations of
the Departmental Promotion Committee, make the
appointments by promotion in the promotion quota vacancies
relevant to the year specified under
