whether the case falls under the category of rarest of rare
cases warranting capital punishment.
7. We heard Shri. A.K. Talesera, learned counsel appearing ... view of the matter, the
case would not fall under the rarest of rare category warranting capital
punishment.
8. Ms. Aparjita Singh, learned counsel appearing
Whether the case in hand can be said to be a `rarest of rare cases'
so as to enable the courts below to award ... inconsistent with Mithu (supra) and
Bachan Singh (supra).
2. THRESHOLD OF RAREST OF RARE
2(A). Sentencing Procedure
The analytical tangle relating to sentencing procedure
enormity
to the extent of rushing into the category of the “rarest of rare
case.”
It is pertinent to mention that in spite ... sole criterion of determining whether a case falls under the “rarest of
rare” categories.
11) In Panchhi & Ors. vs. State
heinous offence and their offence falls under the
category of RARE OF RAREST. Their heinous crime has ruined the
informant of this case, his wife ... Supreme Court, this case falls under the heading of RARE OF
RAREST cases. Because of this the guilty held accused persons
Bachcha Babu Rai, Jagat
observation that the case fell in the category of the rarest of
rare cases.
12. The petitioner filed a petition for review of the said ... rule and death sentence an exception, to be imposed in
the “rarest of rare” cases, recording special reasons. In Bachan
Singh (supra), this Court
instrumentality. That ought not to be done save in the
rarest of rare cases when the alternative option is
unquestionably foreclosed.”
(Emphasis supplied ... Bachan Singh (supra) has set a
very high threshold of “rarest of rare cases when the alternative
option is unquestionably foreclosed” for the grant
every case. It may do so “in rarest of rare cases” when
its collective conscience is so shocked that it will
expect the holders ... child, was found sufficient to make Kashmir
Singh’s case a rarest of rare case, shocking the Court’s conscience.
19. In Mukesh v. State
Dattatraya @ Datta Ambo Rokade vs The State Of Maharashtra on 21 February, 2019
Equivalent citations
convict falls within the category of
'rarest of rare' cases. The convict was a married person.
According to PW7 Dr. Madan Mohan ... sentence by
treating the case falling under the category of 'Rarest of
rare cases', as it was a case of calculated, cold-blooded
case of appellant is not falling within the criteria of
"rarest of rare case".
14. Counsel for the appellant has also pointed ... following three guiding broad values are emerging:
(i) Individualised sentencing,
(ii) Rarest of rare case
(iii ) Principled sentencing
47. Individualised sentencing - Effective compliance of sentencing
