hearing i.e., 11.03.2022. He further added that the judgment
of RBI Vs, Jayantilal N Mistry was not a complete code in itself wherein ... reliance on the judgement
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in RBI vs Jayantilal N. Mistry & Ors., in general,
Page
CPIO
and order passed by the FAA and submitted that the CPIO, RBI and FAA had
violated the principles of natural justice, as they ... captioned Second Appeals challenging the
Order issued by the Ld. FAA, RBI as the Ld. FAA has failed to observed that
the applicant has sought
information on various points
including inter-alia is as under:-
(a) RD, RBI New Delhi (Mr. EE Karthak), any official from HRMD RBI New Delhi ... Review officer(named for the purpose of proper notice to CPIO RBI Mumbai)-
Ms. Anupam Sonal(existing CAPIO RBI New Delhi) or any member
privilege document and without written permission from RBI, the
same cannot be provided to any Third party. The appellant further submitted that
the respondent ... Besides, the appellant bank
vehemently argued that the CPIO of RBI while conveying his intention to
disclosure the information, had failed to explain
CPIO
and order passed by the FAA and submitted that the CPIO, RBI and FAA had
violated the principles of natural justice, as they ... submitted that w.r.t the information sought by the original applicant, RBI has
issued notice under section
CPIO
and order passed by the FAA and submitted that the CPIO, RBI and FAA had
violated the principles of natural justice, as they ... impugning the disclosure of their
Inspection Reports or parts thereof by the RBI under the RTI Act , this Hon'ble
Commission has also held
Induslnd Bank Limited for last three years and
supply copies of RBI orders'. After considering the response from Induslnd
Bank Limited, the CPIO decided ... deciding the appeal of the appellant. Simply because the
information which the RBI generates or is available in possession with RBI, it
cannot be disclosed
record.
5. The representative of the appellant submitted that the "RBI has, under its
Master Circular on Prudential norms on Income Recognition Asset
Classification ... accounts furnished by the CPIO in the list as envisaged by the
RBI in the above said circular. He further submitted that in tune with
High Mark Credit Information
Services Pvt. Ltd.)
VERSUS
बनाम
CPIO ... ितवादी/Respondent
RBI, Department of Non-Banking
Supervision Central Office, 2nd Floor,
Centre-1 World ... CPIO
and order passed by the FAA and submitted that the CPIO, RBI and FAA had
violated the principles of natural justice, as they
Jayantilal N. Mistry case made observations
which read as under:-
"the RBI does not place itself in a fiduciary relationship with the
Financial institutions ... statements
of the bank, information related to the business obtained by the RBI are
not under the pretext of confidence or trust. In this case
