cases where the examination in question is a qualifying
examination and cases where the examination in question is a competitive
examination. Coupled with the fact ... University of Health Sciences in
ordering re-verification/ revaluation/re-examination of answer scripts of 436
students, was proper or not. It is, in that
directed to constitute three panels
each constituting of three independent experts for examination
of answer scripts of the respondent/writ petitioner in respect of
questions ... absence of statutory provision, the court
cannot direct reassessment/re‐examination of answer
scripts. The courts normally should not direct the
production of answer scripts
Page 3 of 14
Judicial Assistant is hereby informed that on re-examination/
evaluation of his answer sheets of Paper I and Paper ... petitioner cannot seek re-evaluation of his answer
scripts as there is no provision under the rules for re-evaluation/ re-
examination. In this respect
Court a purported
explanation for not undertaking the exercise of re-examination
on the answer script of the petitioner.
Although there is no apparent statutory ... examine the matter further having regard to the admitted
position that re-examination of the petitioner's answer script
in the manner prescribed
writ
petitioner submits that writ petitioner deposited fees for re-
examination of his answer scripts but instead of re-examination
scrutiny was done. Petitioner ... re-
examine the answer scripts of the petitioner.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, appearing for the University submits
that there is no scope for re-examination since
papers VI and VIII of B. Com. Part-III (3
year Honours) Examination, 2008. The respondent was directed to
produce the answer scripts ... error in calculating the
total marks. The Single Bench observed that re-examination of
answer scripts could not have been done by the Court
basis fresh examination
Patna High Court CWJC No.13083 of 2012 (14)
33
was given chance to appear in another examination. The
Hon‟bel Supreme ... could
possibly vitiate the earlier examination to call for
a fresh attempt by all concerned. The process of
re-evaluation of the answer scripts with
correct, we have to decide whether the re-evaluation of the answer sheets in a competitive examination can be ordered by this Tribunal. In Samir ... relevant rules, no candidate in an examination has got any right whatsoever to claim or ask for re-evaluation of his marks." (emphasis added
method of selection was by way
of a preliminary examination followed by a written
examination and thereafter by conducting viva-voce. The
4
appellants ... preliminary examination held on
08/12/2012. Being successful in the preliminary
examination, they appeared for the written examination on
13/04/2013
provision which provides for re-
evaluation of MBBS Examination Papers.
However, re-evaluation of MBBS can only be
8
ordered in "exceptional cases ... process of re-evaluation because
re-checking involves afresh evaluation of the marks
already awarded whereas re-evaluation involves the
extensive re-assessment
