that reservation in PG
courses must be minimum;
(vi) Even if reservation for the OBC category in the AIQ seats is
constitutionally valid, it ought ... following arguments contending that the
27 percent reservation for the OBC category in AIQ seats is constitutionally valid.
Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General
acting
within the constitutional parameters, create a new kind of
discrimination viz., reservation for students of a
particular university? The literal terms ... generally, unless there is vital
nexus with equal opportunity, broad validation of
university-based reservation cannot be built on the vague
ground that all other
post
3
4
cannot be subjected to reservation. It will result in 100 per
cent reservation, which is not permissible in terms of Articles ... posts in a cadre is a sine qua non for a valid
reservation, affirmed the view taken in Chakradhar Paswan
Vs. State of Bihar
reasons assigned by the Ratna Prabha Committee constitute a valid basis for
validating the law‘ and submitted its report on 27 July ... Tribes were promoted against
reservation and backlog vacancies in excess or contrary to
extent of reservation provided in the reservation orders shall
be adjusted
whether adjustment of reserve category candidates against unreserved vacancies is valid and if so, to what extent and in what manner. Extending horizon ... October, 1989 the aforesaid ordinance was replaced and reservation of O.B.Cs. was validated w.e.f. 20.8.1977. By U.P. Ordinance
generally, unless there is vital nexus with equal opportunity, broad validation of university-based reservation cannot be built on the vague ground that all other ... Attorney General frankly admitted that student agitation, without more, could not validate 'reservation' and that excessive reservation was an obvious inequality. Nor, indeed
each Medical College or Institution without taking into account any reservation validly made, shall be filled on the basis of All India Entrance Examination ... seats is constitutionally valid. In that case, university-wise distribution of seats was upheld by the Court as constitutionally valid, even though
even if the reservation ordered by the Railway Board in favour of the members of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes is valid and within ... Indian Administrative Service. Under Article 16(4) there can be a valid reservation of a specified number of vacancies to be filled by appointment
plurality of posts is a sine qua non for a valid reservation in a single post cadre. Moreover, it was also held that neither ... posts in a cadre is a sine qua non for a valid reservation, affirmed the view taken in Chakradhar Paswan v. State of Bihar
Constitution of India, nor the reservation
policy of the State qua vertical reservation. Thus, we are inclined to hold that ... batch
Act by itself clearly thinks of a valid reservation, despite being a
horizontal one.
10. Section 2 of the Act defines a preferential vacancy
