that reservation in PG
courses must be minimum;
(vi) Even if reservation for the OBC category in the AIQ seats is
constitutionally valid, it ought ... following arguments contending that the
27 percent reservation for the OBC category in AIQ seats is constitutionally valid.
Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General
institutional preference-By
State and Union Territories-If valid. What should be the
extent of such reservation. For admission ... What should be the extent of reservation based on
residence requirement and institutional preference ?
Wholesale reservation made by some of the State of
Governments
acting
within the constitutional parameters, create a new kind of
discrimination viz., reservation for students of a
particular university? The literal terms ... generally, unless there is vital
nexus with equal opportunity, broad validation of
university-based reservation cannot be built on the vague
ground that all other
judgment. True import of that
judgment is that after providing for reservation validly
made, whatever seats remain available for non-reserved
categories, 30% of such ... have said in our
judgment is that after providing for reservation validly
made, whatever seats remain available for non reserved
categories, 30% of such seats
question that arises for our consideration is, whether the reservation by institutional preference is valid? India is one country and all its citizens should equally ... have said in our Judgment is that after providing for reservation validly made, whatever seats remain available for non-reserved categories, 30% of such seats
bear directly on the question raised before us, namely, whether any reservation can be legitimately made in admissions to medical colleges on the basis ... proceed on the basis of the principle that the object of any valid scheme of admissions must be to "select the best candidates
indicates that even though it would be ideal not to have any reservation either on residence requirement or on institutional preference but the students passing ... each medical college or institution, without taking into account any reservation validly made, shall be filled on the basis of All India Entrance Examination
post
3
4
cannot be subjected to reservation. It will result in 100 per
cent reservation, which is not permissible in terms of Articles ... posts in a cadre is a sine qua non for a valid
reservation, affirmed the view taken in Chakradhar Paswan
Vs. State of Bihar
within the State for a specified number of years or
can any reservation in admissions be made for them so as to
give them precedence ... number of open seats after taking into account other
kinds of reservation validly made, the 70 per cent reserva-
tions needs to be reduced
reasons assigned by the Ratna Prabha Committee constitute a valid basis for
validating the law‘ and submitted its report on 27 July ... Tribes were promoted against
reservation and backlog vacancies in excess or contrary to
extent of reservation provided in the reservation orders shall
be adjusted
