merit, it would be appropriate to refer to the principles governing judicial review of the disciplinary matters as emerged from the case ... settled law that the Tribunal has only power of judicial review of the administrative action of the appellate on complaints relating to service conditions
also, he was graded as `Good, which ACR was not reviewed. The Applicants contention in this OA is that :
the ACR below the benchmark ... been taken into consideration by the DPC because it had not been reviewed by the reviewing authority and, therefore, it was an incomplete
Indian Supply Service given from 1981 to 1998-99 had also been reviewed and revised promotion order with reassigned seniority was issued on 8.11.2001. Director ... panel but before DPC could meet, the Government, on a fresh review following the process of restructuring of the organization of DGS&D, took
ground inter alia that the rules do not permit any review of the recommendations of the earlier Incentive Committee by subsequent Incentive Committee. The Commissioner ... given promotion on account of non-availability of vacancy. Furthermore, on review both FIR and DD entry are found silent on exemplary courage and valor
2004 on 21.7.2005 where repelling the objection of the respondents/review applicants as to limitation in view of the decision of the High Court ... condone the delay in filing the RA.
5. Learned counsel of review applicants Shri R.L. Dhawan states that MAs for condonation of delay
relevant ACRs with self-appraisal to the higher officers for report and review. The respondents have violated their own instructions dated 20.07.2005 issued by Secretary ... Director of Education (Admn.) at Annexure A-23 for timely writing and review of ACRs so that promotion is not denied on that account
three level performance appraisal system i.e. (1) Reporting Officer (2) Reviewing Officer and (3) Accepting Officer in the APAR format of ISS Officer from ... note further states that in such cases where the Reporting and Reviewing Authorities award varying and contradictory grades, it becomes difficult for the Secretaries
incentive committee in the year when the vacancies were not available, a review incentive committee did not recommend the names of the applicants ... committee had recommended the claim and approved by the Commissioner to hold review incentive committee and to deny out of turn promotion by recording
entry is upgraded, the applicant shall be considered for promotion by a review DPC to be held within one month from the date of upgradation ... promotion to Grade of SAG w.e.f. 28.12.2005 by holding a Review DPC.
(iv) Direct the respondents to give all consequential benefits
Manager,
DRM Office, Northern Railway,
Delhi Division, State Entry Road,
New Delhi. . Review Applicants
Versus
Sh. Surinder Kumar Dhingra,
S/o Sh. Duni Chand,
Senior ... Mishra, Member (A)
This application has been made for review of the order dated 24.10.2011 passed in OA-3857/2010.
2. The review applicants have
