third party.
5. Mr. Tiku, however, submits that the reasoning in W.P.(C) 2232/2012
for release of third party information that the said ... third party
to make a submission in writing or orally, regarding whether the
information should be disclosed, and such submission of the third
party shall
third party information‟ is that
information which is in fact provided by the third party and further
should be asked by the said third party ... third party" should be read as „and‟. Clearly, information relating to
a third party would also be third party information within the meaning
were maintainable under the RTI Act .
THERE IS NO INHERENT INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN SCR AND RTI
ACT. BOTH ENABLE THE THIRD PARTY TO OBTAIN THE
INFORMATION ... RTI Act. Therefore, it cannot be said that there is any inconsistency
between SCR and RTI Act, regarding providing information to the third
party. Both
section (1) to a third party in respect of any
information or record or part thereof, the third party shall,
within ten days from ... information sought
pertains to a third party, in this case, R&AW, then without notice to such
third party and hearing its views
thereunder that deny the information to a third party
irrespective of their status as a 'third party'. The Respondent was thus
entitled ... third parties, as it
permits only parties involved in a case to access relevant documents,
judgments, or orders. This, they claim, implicitly excludes third parties
been supplied by a third party
and has been treated as confidential by the said third party. Section 19(4)
stipulates that when an appeal ... third party, reasonable opportunity of hearing will be
granted to the third party before the appeal is decided. Third party as
stated above includes
information pertaining to
or which „relates to‟ such third party without affording
such third party an opportunity of being heard on whether
such disclosure should ... other
employee as that would constitute third party information. This Court is
also of the opinion that third party information can only be disclosed
third
party, it would be necessary for the concerned PIO to give a written
notice to the third party. The concerned third party ... Undisputedly, the
information may relate to third parties inasmuch as it relates to the
property of those third parties. However, the information as to
unauthorized
third party and has been
treated as confidential by that third party, then the CPIO or the SPIO shall
give a notice to the third ... information related to a third party can only be
divulged after giving notice to the said third party. In view of the above
Counsel for the Petitioners that the RTI Applicant
could have obtained the information sought in the RTI application from the
Anti-Dumping Authority ... information that is sought by the RTI Applicant is confidential in nature and,
specifically, it is third party information given
