sought to
direct an independent agency to investigate the circumstances under which
Rubabuddin Shaikh, the applicant in Criminal Revision Application ... said order was not challenged by
the CBI, but was challenged by Rubabuddin, the brother of the deceased
Shorabuddin, by filing Criminal Revision Application
present writ
petition were part of the State in Rubabuddin Sheikh 's case,
29
we are of the view that it cannot be said ... above statement of Nayamuddin Shaikh is
corroborated by the statement of Rubabuddin Shaikh dated
18.02.2010 wherein he had stated that Nayamuddin told him
that from
case of Rubabuddin
Sheikh v. State of Gujarat has considered in detail earlier
pronouncements reported in R.S.Sodhi v. State
Narmada Bai Vs. State of Gujarat and Ors. (2011) 5 SCC
79; Rubabuddin Sheikh Vs. State of Gujarat
instance of two brothers of deceased Sohrabuddin,
namely, Nayabuddin Shaikh and Rubabuddin Shaikh, are already
admitted for final hearing by this court, and therefore ... filed by
Nayabuddin Shaikh (Prosecution Witness No.181) and
Rubabuddin Shaikh (Prosecution Witness No.208). Appellants in
these appeals are the victims being brothers
Sit vs Samima
Author: Jayant Patel
Bench: Jayant Patel
CR.MA/15981/2010 148/ 148
also heard Shri Tiwari, the learned counsel
appearing for the First Informant Rubabuddin. He placed reliance
on statements of Govind Singh - Constable, Hazarilal Meena -
Police
Gujarat police, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rubabuddin Sheikh (Supra) has
transferred the investigation to CBI. Therefore, it is requested
