upon a case reported in (2011) 4 Supreme Court Cases, 591 S.N. Narula Versus Union of India and Others. Relevant paragraphs from the case ... Patel's case (supra), the latter decision is a judgment per incuriam. The decision in S.N. Narula's case (supra) was binding
Union of India and others Vs. S.K.Kapoor ,
reported in
(2011) 4 SCC 589, S.N.Narula Vs. Union of India and
others, reported ... also considered the judgments cited at the Bar.
6. In S.N.Narula Vs. Union of India and others
(Supra), the Supreme Court has taken
Union of India and others Vs. S.K.Kapoor ) and 2011 4 SCC 591 ( S.N.Narula Vs. Union of India and others ), wherein ... also the view taken by this Court in the case of S.N.Narula vs. Union of India.
10. In 2011 4 SCC 591 ( S
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision
in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC
591] was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter decision is
a judgment per incuriam. The deci-
sion in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4
SCC 591] was binding
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision in
S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC 591]
was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter de-
cision is a judgment per incuriam. The
decision in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4
SCC 591] was binding
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision
in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC
591] was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter decision is
a judgment per incuriam. The deci-
sion in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4
SCC 591] was binding
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision
in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC
591] was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter decision is
a judgment per incuriam. The deci-
sion in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4
SCC 591] was binding
Suit No.202/10 (New Suit ... vs . Dharmender & Ors. Page 38 Of 46 on
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision
in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC
591] was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter decision is a
judgment per incuriam. The decision
in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC
591] was binding
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision in
S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4 SCC 591]
was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter de-
cision is a judgment per incuriam. The
decision in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4
SCC 591] was binding
