Patel's case though
it has been reported later on.
12. In the case of S.N.Narula, the Court took note ... Patel’s case is per incuriam. We have already
noticed two facts pertaining to S.N. Narula (supra), (i) it ws
rendered
which decided T.V.Patel 's case was not
drawn to the decision in S.N.Narula's case.
6. Deciding Civil Appeal ... S.K.Kapoor , noting the
conflicting destinations reached by two co-ordinate Benches of the Supreme
Court in S.N.Narula's case ( supra
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/07/2025
undefined
(2014) 7 S.C.C. 340; and S.N. Narula vs. Union of India, (2011) 4 S ... Patel s case is per
incuriam. We have already noticed two facts pertaining to S.N. Narula (supra), (i) it ws
rendered
Patel’s
case though it has been reported later on.
12. In the case of S.N.Narula, the Court took note of the fact ... Patel’s case is per incuriam. We have
already noticed two facts pertaining to S.N. Narula (supra), (i) it
ws rendered
Patel's
case(supra), the latter decision is a judgment per
incuriam. The decision in S. N. Narula 's case (supra)
was binding ... Singh 's case (supra) has
considered all earlier judgments including the judgment
in S.N. Narula 's case (supra) which had sounded
S.C.C. 589,
Union of India and others vs. R.P. Singh , (2014) 7 S.C.C. 340; and S.N.
Narula vs. Union ... Union of India vs. S.K. Kapoor (supra), Union of India vs.
R.P. Singh (supra); and S.N.Narula vs. Union of India (supra
also the view taken by this Court in the
case of S.N.Narula vs. Union of India & Others , Civil
Appeal ... Patel 's case(supra), the latter decision is a judgment
per incuriam. The decision in S.N.Narula 's case (supra) was
binding
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision in S.N. Narula
case [(2011) 4 SCC 591] was prior to the decision ... S) 98] , the latter decision is a judgment per
incuriam. The decision in S.N. Narula case [(2011) 4
SCC 591] was binding
under:-
"9. It may be noted that the decision in S.N.Narula 's case (supra) was
prior to the decision ... Patel's case(supra), the latter decision
is a judgment per incuriam. The decision in S.N.Narula 's case (supra)
was binding
noted that the decision in S.N.Narula's
case was prior to the decision in T.V.Patel's case ... Patel's
case, the latter decision is a judgment per incuriam.
The decision in S.N.Narula's case was binding
