hand
and SAIL on the other regarding the supply of the balance 753,461 MT.
SAIL's case was that there was a deliberate ... during the relevant period 2007-08. SAIL's case is that as a result it had
to procure the balance quantity from other sources
National Union Waterfront Workers (2001) 7
SCC 1 (hereafter „the SAIL case‟), the workmen would be entitled to
preference/regular employment in accordance therewith ... Government or the State
Government. Referring to the observations in the SAIL case, it is submitted
that since DIAL is not an entity that carries
same was
inapplicable in the facts of the present case.
SAIL's grounds of challenge
8 2018 SSC OnLine Del 10226
Signature Not Verified ... former case, unless the amount is actually
expended no demand for the ascertained sum can be made.
67. Secondly, in the present case, SAIL
direction contained in paragraph 125 of the judgement rendered in
the SAIL case, the management is bound to give preference to the
erstwhile contract labour ... plea, reliance
was placed on the following judgements:
1
[in short ―SAIL Case‖].
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:VIPIN KUMAR
VALE and AMCI clearly understood that they were to
deal with SAIL‟s case as understood to mean that damages claimed by
SAIL were ... year but even included the short
supply quantity in question. The case of SAIL has to be understood
with reference to the fact that
Project
and the same were submitted to arbitration in a separate case -ICC
Case no. 22326/PTA - and an award dated 16.05.2018 has been
rendered ... barred by the principles of constructive res
judicata. It was SAIL's case that since the claimants had referred
certain disputes arising from
contract price on 3rd
February 2006. It is SAIL's case that after obtaining the PAC Respondent
personnel left the site and the country ... which was only till 13th
June 2005 did not help SAIL's case as far as the majority of the Tribunal
was concerned. That
value, as the reference post (see Orissa University
of Agriculture & Technology case[ Orissa University of
Agriculture & Technology v. Manoj K. Mohanty ... SAIL
case [SAIL v. Dibyendu Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC 122 :
( 2011) 2 SCC (L&S) 192] and National Aluminium Co. Ltd.
case [ National Aluminium
incorrect. The application of the Ralia Ram case ratio for
calculating damages was not apt. In that case it was held by the Supreme
Court ... SAIL. The
parties also agreed that SAIL would supply an additional 10,000 CRC to
Thyssen, at a later date. The material supplied by SAIL
Agriculture & Technology case, UT Chandigarh,
Admn. V. Manju Mathur, SAIL case and National Aluminium Co. Ltd.
case).
42.2 The mere fact that the subject
