2150/2012 as the leading case. We will refer to
the said case as the SAIL Case. In the said case
originally, the appellant company ... assessment.
19. Now it is important that we delve upon the
case of SAIL before the Commissioner, its stand in
the appeal and finally before
para6 in the Constitution
Bench Judgment in the case of SAIL versus National
Union Water Front Workers (Supra) after the contract
was found genuine ... prohibition notification
dated 17th March, 1993 in the instant case, the principal
employer(SAIL) was prohibited to employ any contract labour in
any process, operation
Judge Constitution
Bench of Supreme Court in SAIL's case (supra), whether there is any
conferment of authority on the undertaking by the Central ... Judge Constitution Bench of
the Supreme Court in SAIL's case which interalia holds that the question
whether the undertaking is being carried
temporary/ad-hoc/contract employees. The Apex
Court in the said case has considered all the judgments relating to the
pay scales, more particularly ... SAIL
case [SAIL v. Dibyendu Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC
122 : (2011) 2 SCC (L&S) 192] and National Aluminium
Co. Ltd. case [ National Aluminium
Agriculture & Technology case, UT Chandigarh, Admn.
v. Manju Mathur, SAIL case and National Aluminium
Co. Ltd. case).
xxx xxx xxx
42.10. A comparison between
relied upon the
decision of the Apex Court in the case of Sail and another v.
Awadhesh Singh and others , reported ... Paragraph 6 of the decision of the Apex Court in the
case of Sail and another v. Awadhesh Singh and others , cited
supra
find that this issue is no longer res integra. In the
case of National Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Vs. Commr ... Judgment of Chhattisgarh High Court, as to how the
decision in SAIL case has been distinguished. At Paragraph
High Court
of Calcutta in the case of SAIL DSP VR Employees Association 1998 vs. Union
of India (2003) 128 Taxman 704 (Calcutta) wherein ... theHon'ble High Court of Calcutta in the case of SAIL DSP VR Employees Association
1998 vs. Union of India (2003) 128 Taxman
Supreme Court in
11
Excise Appeal Nos. 503 of 2005
SAIL's case (supra) covers the instant cases. It is thus
conclusively established that ... period and therefore the decision of
the Supreme Court in SAIL 's case (supra) continues to be applicable.
6.5 SAIL, DSP has also contended
also referred to the some other cases as listed below in support of
the respondents' case:-
(i) SAIL & another -Vrs- Awadhesh Singh ... introduced categorization of compassionate
employment as First Priority Cases, Second Priority Cases and Third Priority Cases. The
circular reads as below:
"The system
