ques-
tion of validity of the impugned circular within the scope
of judicial review.
(7) The scope of judicial review permissible in the
present case ... validity of the impugned circular
within the scope of judicial review.
The scope of judicial review permissible in the present
case, does not require
record.
The Hon'ble Apex Court while dealing with the scope review in the
case of N. Anantha Reddy (supra) has held as under ... merits.
The Hon'ble Apex Court while dealing with the scope review in the
case of Kamlesh Verma (supra) has held as under
main contents of the application, we are
referring to the scope of review.
11. Now, we are considering the scope of review -
The scope ... observed that the review
is not an appeal in disguise. The scope of review as well as the appeal
is completely different. While the review
such a case the question would be what is the
scope of judicial review? The court could interfere in the
following three categories of cases ... counsel, in his reply,
would submit that as regards the scope of judicial review
the American cases cited by Mr K.K. Venugopal would
Joshi Technologies International Inc vs Union Of India & Ors on 14 May, 2015
Equivalent
judicial review in
American context, summarized as under:
"If the scope of review is too broad,
agencies are turned into little more
than media ... right to review becomes
meaningless...in the final analysis,
the scope of review depends on the
individual judges estimate of the
justice of the case
controversy narrows down to the determination of
the scope and ambit of judicial review i.e. in other words,
to the area of justiciability ... permissible in such cases in
view of the limited scope of judicial review in such cases.
I am, therefore, in respectful agreement with the view
with the review, Rule 1 of which
provides:
“1. The Court may review its
judgment or order, but no
application for review will be
entertained ... this Court has occasion
again to consider the ambit and scope of review
jurisdiction in P.N. Eswara Iyer and others
vs. Registrar , Supreme Court
controversy narrows down to the determination of
the scope and ambit of judicial review i.e. in other words,
to the area of justiciability ... permissible in such cases in
view of the limited scope of judicial review in such cases.
I am, therefore, in respectful agreement with the view
While considering the aforesaid submissions/reliefs sought, the scope
of judicial review on the policy decisions having financial implications
which might affect the economy ... this Court had an occasion to
consider in detail the scope of judicial review. While considering the other
decisions of this Court on the limited
