judicial review in American context, summarized as under:
"If the scope of review is too broad, agencies are turned into little
more than media ... right to review becomes meaningless...in the final
analysis, the scope of review depends on the individual judges
estimate of the justice of the case
passed under political pressure.
6. There is a very little scope of judicial review by
Courts/Tribunals against the transfer order and the same ... Court
should be reluctant in interfering in transfer orders. The
scope of judicial review in the matter of transfer of a
Government employee is limited
reported in 2013 AIR SCW 1316, has held that scope
of review petition is very limited and submissions made on
questions of fact cannot ... judgment suffered from
some material irregularity which required
of
correction in review. The scope of a review
petition is very limited and the
submissions advanced
State
Unit and others (2009) 8 SCC 46.
25. The scope of judicial review and its exclusion was
a subject matter of a recent decision ... appellate authority on an opinion."
26. Notably, scope of judicial review was yet again
subject matter of a very recent decision rendered
Supreme Court therein had
been discussing qua dealing with the scope of judicial review
regarding the correctness of the key answers and it was held ... HCHP
-5-
15. The issue pertaining to scope of judicial review of correctness of
key answer had been considered by this Court time and again
passed under political pressure.
6. There is a very little scope of judicial review by Courts/Tribunals
against the transfer order and the same ... Court should be
reluctant in interfering in transfer orders. The scope of
judicial review in the matter of transfer of a Government
employee is limited
public interest. It was held that:-
"8. The scope of judicial review in matters relating to award
of contract by the State ... Cochin International Airport Ltd. (2000) 1 SCR 505).
10. The scope of judicial review in contractual matters was
further examined by this Court in Tata
order that Review Petition
.
No. 133 of 2015 has been preferred. Therefore, at this
stage, I deem it proper to consider the Review Petition ... merits of
the petition, this Court is required to consider the
scope of review.
44. Learned Division Bench of this Court in
Kameshwar Sharma
Order 47 Rule 1
CPC .
5. What would be the scope of review was considered
by this Court in Kameshwar Sharma and others vs. State ... reported in 2013 AIR SCW 1316, has held that scope of
review petition is very limited and submissions made on
questions of fact cannot
such circumstances, the moot question is: what
would be the scope of judicial review in the given facts and
circumstances of the case. This question ... Ramesh (2010) 8 SCC 372.
15. Examining the scope of judicial review
with regards to re-evaluation of answer sheets,
::: Downloaded on - 14/07/2023
