alleged clandestine removal of processed fabrics, is on the basis of rough scribbling papers recovered from the factory of the assessee company, which ... further submits no statement of the writer of the rough scribbling was recorded. It is submitted that the Central Excise Officers attempted to corroborate these
year 2008-09 and for assessment year 2008-
09, based on some scribbling which are not dated or clear, Assessing
Officer quantified the amounts advanced ... AVGR/Res/04 have been perused and
they are only some scribbling i.e., Gurivi owes Bujji on page19
and some amounts were scribbled
this, loose sheet No.103 in
ANN/PS/LS/IMP had some scribbling regarding the on-money,
brokerage etc. made in respect of an immovable ... business and construction business and relied on the some loose sheet
and scribbling payments in respect of immovable property and deposition
of C.K. Natarajan
assessee is not mentioned. The papers are in the nature of rough scribbling.
The Ld A.R also submitted that the assessee was not given ... mention name of the assessee, some of the documents
contain rough scribbling and calculations. In our view, the rough scribbling
made, computations etc. would
copy of the notice Exhibit 35
where the printed date was scribbled and another
date of 17th January 2012 was written by hand.
This Advocate
even this Court also cannot read it. It is written scribble and no one
except the person who has written it, can read it. Mere
2016 00:59:51 :::
Criminal Appeal No.868/2015
18
some scribbling like Doctor's make in the time ... scribbling has not been proved, but if the
evidence of P.W.5 Dr. Anil is perused, the evidence is that,
the complainant was brought
figure of 12.59 lacs has been worked out from the scribbling
recorded on the given seized papers. It has also not been pointed
Siddharth Ashwinbhai Parekh vs Vir Narmad South Gujarat University & 2 on 26 April, 2016
document, has
substantial bearing on the question whether a mere scribbling on
WP 2564/2012
3
a plain piece of paper can tantamount to either
